![]() |
|
HS waste of money - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: HS waste of money (/showthread.php?tid=29166) Pages:
1
2
|
HS waste of money - Derek Hardballs - 03-09-2023 Not content with fking the environment up, it continues to fk communities over and doesn’t give a flying fck how much it goes over budget! It’s only money It’s only a couple of b RE: HS waste of money - Borin' Baggie - 03-09-2023 Imagine being opposed to HS2. RE: HS waste of money - Ournextstriker - 03-09-2023 What does Gary Lineker think? RE: HS waste of money - Derek Hardballs - 03-09-2023 (03-09-2023, 02:47 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Imagine being opposed to HS2. Imagine thinking it offered any real value RE: HS waste of money - Protheroe - 03-09-2023 (03-09-2023, 02:52 PM)Ournextstriker Wrote: What does Gary Lineker think? If he paid the £5 million he owed in tax we could build an extra yard of track. RE: HS waste of money - Borin' Baggie - 03-09-2023 (03-09-2023, 03:33 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(03-09-2023, 02:47 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Imagine being opposed to HS2. It does, improving railway capacity is a huge value. The Shinkansen got the exact same criticisms in the 60s, now the people criticising it look like idiots. The TGV got the same criticisms, now the people criticising it look like idiots. So did the direttissima, the ICE, HS1, AVE, KTX, HSL etc etc etc. All the people criticising those initiatives now look like idiots. Maybe if NIMBYs like you accepted the overwhelming pile of evidence instead of obstructing it at every point then it would have been built by now at a much lower cost? But oh no, can't improve the UK's infrastructure. Do you know what the most congested railway line in Europe is? The Rugby-Wolverhampton spur on the WCML. Most overcrowded not in the UK but all of Europe. That is the value of HS2. RE: HS waste of money - Protheroe - 03-09-2023 (03-09-2023, 03:41 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Maybe if NIMBYs like you accepted the overwhelming pile of evidence instead of obstructing it at every point then it would have been built by now at a much lower cost? NIMBYs will never reach the "Are We The Bad Guys?" stage BB... RE: HS waste of money - Tom Joad - 03-09-2023 Borin' Baggie Wrote:Derek Hardballs Wrote:Borin' Baggie Wrote:Imagine being opposed to HS2. Where the arguments for HS2 fall down for me are firstly the speed. It saves virtually no time at all by the time you get yourself from Curzon St to Brum. Next capacity, by pricing it anything like HS1 there will be hardly anyone on it and the reason given is always expense. Third, by having few stops in order to be fast and direct, many commuters won't be able to use it as it doesn't stop in many commuter towns. Making it exclusive is the opposite of any mass transit system. I'm all for increasing capacity, I was on rammed trains, Moor St to Marylebone and again Euston to New St, just the other week. I just think there may have been a better plan. RE: HS waste of money - Borin' Baggie - 03-09-2023 (03-09-2023, 04:38 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:Borin' Baggie Wrote:Derek Hardballs Wrote:Borin' Baggie Wrote:Imagine being opposed to HS2. Curzon Street is right next to Moor Street, Moor Street to Marylebone is viable so I don't see why Curzon Street wouldn't be. Once you factor in transport connections (the tram) it should be fine - 10 minutes to Brindley Place, Jewelry Quarter and Digbeth. It's also has much better access to central Brum compared with most of the London termini, Manchester Piccadilly, Bristol Temple Meads etc. As for virtually no time, it does not take 40 minutes to walk from Curzon Street to Birmingham New Street station (also there's the tram). And if you want to get from Stourbridge to London then the connection at Curzon Street is right there at Moor Street. Yes in a perfect world you'd expand New Street but 7 new underground platforms for New Street will cost £3bn more to build. UK HS1 tickets are only 20% more than the slow services, there's a greater gap between Avanti IC WCML services and the LNWR stopper. They're not prohibitively expensive relative to other options, and the benchmark will be the existing IC services as that's what is being moved onto HS2. HS2 isn't meant for commuters, it's meant to take away the IC services so more commuter trains can run on the WCML. Having fewer conflicting services enables more stopper services and opens up the potential for more train stations to open. Not to mention, as Birmingham New Street is a through station not having to accommodate the IC shuttles means more services on lines via the Cross City line. That is the capacity benefit. Not to mention freight, less conflict on the Immingham-Southampton path (via Coventry) and less competition with faster services on the WCML in Birmingham means more freight can run and 1 freight train = 76 44t HGVs. Towns like Tipton, Redditch, Coleshill etc will have massively improved services into Birmingham as a result of HS2 improving WCML capacity. Then there's future capacity benefits from services to Manchester and Nottingham (though probably not with the level of chronic short sightedness this country has with infrastructure). Do I think HS2 is perfect? No, far from it and I made several objections to HS2 Ltd and the DfT over it when I was working on a parallel project a few years ago. Do I think it's necessary, absolutely having looked at the data. Birmingham New Street is on the most congested section of railway in Europe, that is the main station of the second biggest city in the UK. And ultimately, railway projects in this country are an absolute joke because people are too scared to build the necessary infrastructure. HS2 is already massively scaled back from what it should be, the line to Bristol isn't even electrified, the WCML upgrade plans (four-tracking between Coventry and Birmingham and 140mph operation) were scrapped despite infrastructure being planned to accommodate it, Birmingham/the West Midlands had an underground MRT rejected and government rules mean it can't plan long term for the metro as it only gets funding piece by piece, the SNP completely screwed up the Edinburgh light and heavy railway plans because they didn't want it etc etc etc. If we'd just got on with building HS2 when it was known that we needed to build it then it would have been done by the 1990s at a fraction of the cost but unfortunately the need to build it hasn't disappeared. RE: HS waste of money - Protheroe - 03-09-2023 BB is right. You can see the same dynamics at play with the Midlands Metro. The original plan (in the 1980s FFS) was a straight line south east to the NEC. Instead we ended up with a pig in a poke down an old railway line to Wolverhampton and an obsession with excessively expensive little city centre extensions when it should have been all the way down Hagley Road too to the new park and ride at Quinton Meadows that'll never be completed. How we've gone from leading the world in metro, rail and road engineering to the absolute basket case we are pandering to all sorts of irrelevant sectional interests is everything that's wrong with this country. |