![]() |
|
Yesterday - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Yesterday (/showthread.php?tid=28248) Pages:
1
2
|
Yesterday - MancBaggie - 01-03-2023 Slightly strange game yesterday. Probably a better result than performance overall and 4 games in 12 days took its toll. Of course we should of been out of sight after 15 mins but after that (apart from a 10 min spell before the goal) we were slightly tepid and allowed an average side way too much possession and a shot at nicking an under deserved point. Ince gets a lot of stick as manager but he is doing a decent job keeping Reading out of the bottom 6. It wasnt a comfortable 1-0 but we were not last ditch defending either. But at 1-0, the opposition can always throw a ball in and nick an equaliser. Happily their best chance didnt fall to any of the 4 strikers who were on the pitch at various times. Marks Palmer 7 One error 2nd half but sound otherwise and a good save at 0-0. Looks mature and swept up the Reading through balls well - where they tried to get behind the 2 advanced c halfs Furlong 6.5 Still lacks that final ball from an attacking sense but his defending/ positioning has improved markedly. Slightly slow to a couple of 2nd balls late on yesterday Townsend 7 His decline is well documented but thought he was better yesterday. Slightly unlucky with the header from the angle, he tried to overlap but was given some overhit balls by both MP and Grady. Solid enough Pieters 7 Got done first half but recovered well against Meite, otherwise the defence looks solid/ well drilled with him in it (despite his individual limitations). Surprised he was hooked - presumably picked up a knock Dara 7 Competed against Carroll and tried to get us moving with some quick passing/spreading. Think it was his error that gave Reading their big chance first half - but v good otherwise Molumby 8 Possibly the best of a bad bunch under Bruce, played v well here. Energy, good passing and often made an overlap with Furlong. Deserved the assist. Rushed his passing last 20 when in decent positions Okay 7.5 was outstanding for 65 minutes. Dictated the play and showed great feet in tight areas. Like Molumby, he also covered in front of AC to stop him winning headers. Tired late on and needed to keep the ball better Swift 6.5 Started well and only thing lacking was that energy/burst onto the penalty spot when the wingers were ready to cut the ball back. He would then get a lot more chances. Faded after that and played some poor balls when well placed. Not totally convinced by him yet Wallace 7 Started brightly and gave us good width as usual. Some great crosses that we should of benefitted from but not quite in the game enough overall. Key player for us - especially with Dike as a target MP 6 Played some great crosses in early on - after starting with intent. Faded badly after that and rightly subbed. He's one who really does struggle with a batch of games - rested/illness or not Dike 7 Should of buried that early chance and might have done better with 2 first half headers. Off the boil before the HT break re-energised him. Good spin for the free kick and a nice glancing header. He needs to score more goals like that Grady 5 Was the right sub but thought he was v poor. Constant wrong decisions, tricks in the wrong areas (instead of the last third when it mattered) and again doesnt get enough shots off. He needs to improve his end product, as we still need him Assante 6.5 Usual effort and unsettled their back line with limited service. One fine cutback to Grady. He might have done better with the header and should certainly played in TGH earlier when we needed that 2nd TGH 6.5 Good to see him get game time and helped get a foot in when we defended deep late on. Eager to break too - when we needed to ease the pressure Rogic 6 Tried to play some passes but gave it away cheaply when we needed poise. Still more of a 30 min player IMO Semi - not on long enough RE: Yesterday - Shabby Russian - 01-03-2023 I think the marks are pretty spot on. But I do think it was a comfortable win, or as comfortable as a 1-0 can be. Suspect a lot of posters are giving too much emphasis to the last 15 mins, and not enough to the previous 75 mins. You would expect a side 1 goal down to push forward and cause problems at the end of the game. The only thing I would find fault with us yesterday was that we were only 1 goal up going into the last 15 minutes of the game. RE: Yesterday - Spandaubaggie - 01-03-2023 Good marks. Hard to disagree with much. I would say it was a below par Matt Phillips performance and Grady was as uninspiring when he came on. Shabby seems adamant that was a comfortable 1-0, but really can't see it. Their header in the 86th minute was near a sitter and we looked very lethargic last 20 mins. It was one of those days we got away with it. I would say a similar game with Bruce we would have drawn and seen him ruing missed chances and bad luck. That's the difference now. We seem to make more luck and that's not by chance. RE: Yesterday - MancBaggie - 01-03-2023 I agree with the observation on the overweighting of the last 15 Shabb - but otherwise Im more with Spandau than you here (I saw your post yesterday that also said similar). I dont think it was a comfortable 1-0. Given the margin was so slim, we should of therefore worked much harder at keeping the ball and trading attacks with Reading. But in fairness CC does play this way and has enough faith in his organisation/set-up to defend narrow leads. Hudds did the very thing to us last season at their place. We had a similar 1-0 home win against Reading (under Val) just last year. I thought that was more comfortable than this one. RE: Yesterday - Hopalong - 01-03-2023 (01-03-2023, 02:07 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: Slightly strange game yesterday. Probably a better result than performance overall and 4 games in 12 days took its toll. Of course we should of been out of sight after 15 mins but after that (apart from a 10 min spell before the goal) we were slightly tepid and allowed an average side way too much possession and a shot at nicking an under deserved point. Ince gets a lot of stick as manager but he is doing a decent job keeping Reading out of the bottom 6. Good analysis. That extra game against Cov took its toll. I think Semi was brought on to counter the ale-house balls into our box in the last 10 though Pieters did get a knock but still looked surprised when hooked. I think Dike would have scored from the header Asante just missed. But wise to manage his minutes. Hopefully as games get spread out a little Carlos won't need to make so many subs so early as it definitely disrupts things (apart from Sunderland ). Grady is such a disappointment and he's the next one Carlos really needs to get hold of and help him to re-find himself. RE: Yesterday - Fido - 01-03-2023 Agreed on Grady, Athers. There were at least four occasions when we were in decent positions on the left wing and he lost it or got bumped off it. I know he's not DD it terms of stature but it was like taking sweets from a baby. Reading then had the chance to counter quickly and he wasn't exactly breaking his back to win the ball back. RE: Yesterday - Tom Joad - 01-03-2023 Good marks Manc. I wouldn't take issue with much of that. For me, the two backs are doing ok defensively but both lack the final ball when pushing forward. So frustrating but I suppose we are now a mid table Champ club and it's about par. Glad you pointed out the error by Palmer. Despite our unbridled joy at finding someone that can actually make a save, he does let a few across the goal area. I'm told that's the modern way with keepers but I prefer someone that makes the area a war zone for forwards. Anyway, as always, he steps up when needed and I believe will only get better. I would also have marked Molumby up a notch. He was absolutely top drawer yesterday and you'd never believe he'd played as many games as the others. Agree about Ince. He is doing a good job there and I thought Reading were quite decent, tactically spot on after riding their luck 1st 20. Also notice they played much more on the deck after Carroll went off, they stretched us but not enough. Just glad their keeper wasn't in a position to waste any time after the hour mark as he was shaping up to wind us right up. Personally I thought the ref should have had more nous than he did letting things go. I think CC expected Rogic and Grady to have a bit more to put in than they did. Their inability to cause problems led to Reading getting back into the game. TGH would have been a better option. It was a 1 - 0 so we can argue all we like how easy or hard it was but for me had they equalised it would have been very harsh. RE: Yesterday - Bob Fossil - 01-03-2023 Townsend has had 3 or 4 decent chances in the last few games, including hitting the post yesterday, when coming in at the back post onto (usually) Wallace's crosses, which is really encouraging for me. If he can find a bit of confidence and actually put one away, it could kick him on. Best game for a while yesterday, a solid 7, so Carlos is definitely having a positive impact. Same with Furlong, who I also thought was a solid 7. Molumby was superb though, with a Yokuslu level performance. Would have given him a 9, but he cost me £100 when he missed his chance as I'd backed him for 1st goal, so I'll go with the 8! We need some mad scientist to shove Swift and Rogic into a blender. The result would be worth £20m. RE: Yesterday - MancBaggie - 01-03-2023 (01-03-2023, 03:18 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Good marks Manc. I wouldn't take issue with much of that. Absolutely RE: Yesterday - Cuzer - 01-03-2023 Never wide of the mark as always Manc Pieters seemed to have the right hump when hooked so I can only imagine it was tactical and Semi was brought on for his aerial prowess against Reading's lumps up top On that Palmer first half save, every replay I've seen looks like Okay clered it before it got to Palmer, I was in the Brummy as usual and still not 100% sure, watch the behind the goal replay Cuzer |