WBAUnofficial
Do we need to talk about Karlan? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Do we need to talk about Karlan? (/showthread.php?tid=27229)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


Do we need to talk about Karlan? - Shabby Russian - 10-19-2022

Are we going to have to play him out wide again?

Overall this season, from what I have seen, Diangana has played well, last night being an exception. But I still think we are not seeing enough end product...not entirely his fault.

Grant may be a limited footballer, but his record at this level in terms of goals scored and assists is good. Especially for a player, playing in a wide position.

People say, and perhaps with some justification, that he is a good player for a side struggling in the bottom half of the table. That might be us at the moment.


RE: Do we need to talk about Karlan? - Derek Hardballs - 10-19-2022

(10-19-2022, 07:20 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Are we going to have to play him out wide again?

Overall this season, from what I have seen, Diangana has played well, last night being an exception. But I still think we are not seeing enough end product...not entirely his fault.

Grant may be a limited footballer, but his record at this level in terms of goals scored and assists is good. Especially for a player, playing in a wide position.

People say, and perhaps with some justification, that he is a good player for a side struggling in the bottom half of the table. That might be us at the moment.

It’s because three up top with two wingers not wide forwards doesn’t work. Go back to basics and play 442 as we don’t have the personnel for the system we are currently playing.


RE: Do we need to talk about Karlan? - Cunninghamismagic - 10-19-2022

Send him back to Huddersfield as not fit for purpose


RE: Do we need to talk about Karlan? - Duffers - 10-19-2022

(10-19-2022, 07:56 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: Send him back to Huddersfield as not fit for purpose

Whatever his flaws as a player his goal scoring record at Championship level suggests he is fit for purpose.

He’s proven capable of scoring goals, the question is getting him in the right position to do so.


RE: Do we need to talk about Karlan? - Lurker#3 - 10-19-2022

Where or not he's good enough, we look less of a threat with him not in the team.

---------------------- Palmer ---------------------
--- Livermore --- O'Shea --- Okay ------
Wallace ---- TGH ----- Swift ----- Townsend
------------------------- Grady -------------------------
----------------- BTA ---------- Cleary -----------

As stated above wingers in a front three don't work. Or else you end up with one up front and a back 6/7.

Grady in a free role with the sole aim to get close to the front 2 and provide. The front two should never be more than 20m apart either. We are so poor when it comes to developing partnerships on the pitch. Grant is the next cab off the rank, but needs to make an impact off the bench.


RE: Do we need to talk about Karlan? - WorcsWBA - 10-19-2022

(10-19-2022, 08:21 AM)Duffers Wrote: Whatever his flaws as a player his goal scoring record at Championship level suggests he is fit for purpose.

He’s proven capable of scoring goals, the question is getting him in the right position to do so.

Which is as the left-sided forward in a front 3 of course. I can't see that he's ever going to become more versatile than that, sadly.


RE: Do we need to talk about Karlan? - Cheshire East Baggie - 10-19-2022

(10-19-2022, 08:42 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Where or not he's good enough, we look less of a threat with him not in the team.

---------------------- Palmer ---------------------
--- Livermore --- O'Shea --- Okay ------
Wallace ---- TGH ----- Swift ----- Townsend
------------------------- Grady -------------------------
----------------- BTA ---------- Cleary -----------

As stated above wingers in a front three don't work. Or else you end up with one up front and a back 6/7.

Grady in a free role with the sole aim to get close to the front 2 and provide. The front two should never be more than 20m apart either. We are so poor when it comes to developing partnerships on the pitch. Grant is the next cab off the rank, but needs to make an impact off the bench.

Lurker, you keep floating this idea of playing Okay and Jake in the back three. Why would the tired Livermore and out-of-form Yokuslu do better in unfamiliar positions than the not-match-fit Kelly and elderly Pieters? Your line-up would be disastrously weak on our right flank - Livermore and Wallace??? As Derek says, we have to go 442 and try coaching the defence instead of just shuffling it.


RE: Do we need to talk about Karlan? - Lurker#3 - 10-19-2022

(10-19-2022, 09:00 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(10-19-2022, 08:42 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Where or not he's good enough, we look less of a threat with him not in the team.

---------------------- Palmer ---------------------
--- Livermore --- O'Shea --- Okay ------
Wallace ---- TGH ----- Swift ----- Townsend
------------------------- Grady -------------------------
----------------- BTA ---------- Cleary -----------

As stated above wingers in a front three don't work. Or else you end up with one up front and a back 6/7.

Grady in a free role with the sole aim to get close to the front 2 and provide. The front two should never be more than 20m apart either. We are so poor when it comes to developing partnerships on the pitch. Grant is the next cab off the rank, but needs to make an impact off the bench.

Lurker, you keep floating this idea of playing Okay and Jake in the back three. Why would the tired Livermore and out-of-form Yokuslu do better in unfamiliar positions than the not-match-fit Kelly and elderly Pieters? Your line-up would be disastrously weak on our right flank - Livermore and Wallace??? As Derek says, we have to go 442 and try coaching the defence instead of just shuffling it.

Because without Semi or Clarke (last season) we have nobody at the back who can pass effective through the lines and also handle the ball under pressure. Most of the issues we have defensively are caused by a lack of bravery in terms of keeping our line and compacting the game. 

I feel Kelly offers nothing. Pieters I am okay with but not sure he's a CB at all, and both Livermore and Okay have played CB in a three at a high level, Jake at Hull in the Prem and Champ and Okay in Spain. Jake is a perfectly decent defensive player and with Wallace's & TGHs work rate, along with keeping a strong line and reducing space between the lines it would be fine.

I keep saying to folk that good defensive teams don't need to be littered with cloggers. Man city are super defensively and play with only 1 holder and 2 CBs. But they are drilled to within an inch of their lives and their offensive players do their jobs.

Basically I am sick of the same, ineffective, 'tried and tested', outdated crap, which a blunt 442 is. We dont have the mobility in central areas (CB/CM) for it. 

With a fully fit squad I would go a back 3 of Semi, O'Shea and Okay.


RE: Do we need to talk about Karlan? - CA Baggie - 10-19-2022

Grant would do better in a 343, playing to the left of a big man. Anything else is a waste of a shirt.

When we have the players back, for me it has to be:

Palmer
Kelly O'Shea Ajayi Pieters
TGH Yokuslu
Wallace Rogic or Swift Diang
Dike


RE: Do we need to talk about Karlan? - Cheshire East Baggie - 10-19-2022

Sorry to keep questioning your defensive ideas, Lurker, but I'm bemused by your suggestion that Semi and Clarke were the players who could pass out from the back and were comfortable on the ball. Clarke maybe could stroll out with a bit of swagger, but Ajayi always looks like a startled kitten with the ball at his feet. Appalling first touch and passing not even as good as O'Shea. Semi Ajayi is truly a player who gets better with each game he doesn't play  Big Grin