WBAUnofficial
Grady vs Grant - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Grady vs Grant (/showthread.php?tid=26264)

Pages: 1 2


Grady vs Grant - Bob Fossil - 08-24-2022

IF (that's a big if, in case you hadn't noticed), we bring in the required striker or 2, who should play on the left, Grady or Grant.

For me they are polar opposites so it's a kicker of a question.

Grady:
Pros - Good feet, scares defenders, not scared to run with the ball, wins free-kicks.
Cons - Comes up massively short in terms of goals and assists.

Grant:
Pros - Scores more than his fair share, chips in with assists, takes a decent penalty.
Cons - Offers little in open play, doesn't scare defenders, easy to play against.

Like I say, polar opposites, but, I have to say, in this league and despite Grady's terrific start, I'd probably go with Grant. Pains me to say it but his goals and assists will be far more valuable than Grady's flair and excitement. Is this sacrilege?


RE: Grady vs Grant - Lightnin - 08-24-2022

Play 4-4-2 and play them both.


RE: Grady vs Grant - HLS - 08-24-2022

Merge the two and we have the Grady from 3 years ago.

Heart says Grady. Head says Grant.

I'd stick with Grady as his all round game is better (defensively too) and bring Grant on for a midfielder (Molumby or Livermore) if we're chasing the game. 

Though if we're expecting we'll get a striker better than Grant I think we will unfortunately have to lower our expectations.


RE: Grady vs Grant - MassDebater - 08-24-2022

Worst case is that one of them comes off the bench chomping at the bit to get their starting place back...that's got to be good for us?


RE: Grady vs Grant - Sliced - 08-24-2022

I think it depends who we have up top.

For a finisher I'd go with Grady. If it was more of a target man like Carroll I'd probably go with Grant.


RE: Grady vs Grant - Dumbo - 08-24-2022

Grady.

He’s looking somewhat back to his best, which is one of the best players in the division.

Grants a great option to have on the bench and start the odd match up top.


RE: Grady vs Grant - SW4Baggie - 08-24-2022

"Which do we accrue more points with?"

Grady does a lot more than just provide goals and assists.

I think we are a better team with Grady on the left than Grant, and provided we have an alternative number 9, I feel we will score more with Grady there.


RE: Grady vs Grant - Shabby Russian - 08-24-2022

(08-24-2022, 12:11 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: "Which do we accrue more points with?"

Grady does a lot more than just provide goals and assists.

I think we are a better team with Grady on the left than Grant, and provided we have an alternative number 9, I feel we will score more with Grady there.

And if that is correct then obviously Diangana is the one to play.

But I wonder what evidence you have to back this up.

We know Grant is good for a goal tally in the high teens, plus a handful of assists.

Is Diangana good enough to replicate those stats or play In a way that allows others to replace Grant's goals.


RE: Grady vs Grant - Remi_Moses - 08-24-2022

Easy decision "Grant"


RE: Grady vs Grant - SW4Baggie - 08-24-2022

(08-24-2022, 12:26 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(08-24-2022, 12:11 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: "Which do we accrue more points with?"

Grady does a lot more than just provide goals and assists.

I think we are a better team with Grady on the left than Grant, and provided we have an alternative number 9, I feel we will score more with Grady there.

And if that is correct then obviously Diangana is the one to play.

But I wonder what evidence you have to back this up.

We know Grant is good for a goal tally in the high teens, plus a handful of assists.

Is Diangana good enough to replicate those stats or play In a way that allows others to replace Grant's goals.

No evidence SR - just saying for me it's not about how many goals Grant scores and Grady directly matching or beating that tally, but which leads to better results, along with  which one will better suit the game plan for that opposition. I'd rather Grady scored 5 and assisted 5 and we won 10xgames 1-0 than Grant scored 20 and we drew 10 games 2-2.

I believe he is, and I think we will be a better team with him in the side as he will create more space and opportunity for Swift and Wallace than Grant will... but we will need a number 9 in to know for sure.