WBAUnofficial
Darren Moore future poll. - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Darren Moore future poll. (/showthread.php?tid=2495)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


Darren Moore future poll. - SW4Baggie - 03-02-2019

Just out of interest really, as seems quite a few strong opinions on here.


RE: Darren Moore future poll. - Dumbo - 03-02-2019

https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/showthread.php?tid=347&pid=5699#pid5699


RE: Darren Moore future poll. - SW4Baggie - 03-02-2019

(03-02-2019, 11:14 AM)Dumbo Wrote: https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/showthread.php?tid=347&pid=5699#pid5699

Nothing has changed since that post?

I wasn’t advocating sacking him, but a month on, nothing has improved, if anything it’s worsened. 

As I posted last night, I massively appreciate the job he’s done turning round a sinking ship, but it seems we require a different skill set, and one he at present doesn’t have, and doesn’t appear to be learning. If it wasn’t so time-precious I’d give him longer.

Not getting promotion a few weeks ago didn’t seem sack-worthy, but the approach in the last 4-5 games and the ongoing stubbornness in tactics at home, has IMO cost us a top 2 place and that probably is.


RE: Darren Moore future poll. - KratosBaggie - 03-02-2019

We're in a play off position and still have a reasonable chance to get promoted. What do people expect? He's made mistakes, and has no doubt cost us points due to his tactics and decision, but come on, you can't knock his results overall.


RE: Darren Moore future poll. - EastMidsBaggie - 03-02-2019

Difficult one and kind of one of the reasons he wasn't favourite to get the job for me; really don't want his Albion status tainted and don't want the fans turning against him. However, we really have to be seen in moving forward and being serious challengers; learning from mistakes; tactical nous to change things even mid game etc.
At the moment we seen to be stalling or falling slightly backwards on all accounts rather than getting stronger as I expected as the season moved on.
Not advocating any change yet and still backing him but very worrying signs that need addressing during our (comparatively) easy run in and then seen how we do in the POs (if we fail to even get there then I think he's gone anyway).

(03-02-2019, 11:19 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: We're in a play off position and still have a reasonable chance to get promoted. What do people expect? He's made mistakes, and has no doubt cost us points due to his tactics and decision, but come on, you can't knock his results overall.

Not a 'reasonable' chance now.
Some really good and some really bad performances and results but the home form (where the majority of your fans watch and engage) has been woeful and needs to be addressed.


RE: Darren Moore future poll. - HawkingsHalfpint - 03-02-2019

I don’t see the point in sacking him during this campaign - to do that only sends out a message to any successor that only automatic promotion is acceptable; and that really isn’t a great prospect for any coach who will know that they may well be faced with further squad upheaval come summer.

There is an argument that there is time for one last push with an experienced expert at the helm, but there is no guarantee either that anyone suitable is available; nor that they can actually do the job.

So, for me, it all depends upon where we end up in May. I think if we make the play-offs, then win-or-lose he deserves to be here for the curtain raiser in August. Although achievable, the top two was always going to be a tall order, and as said ad-nauseum most of us would have accepted play-offs back at the start of the season.

I think if we finish below 6th place then he probably has to go. This squad - although limited in some ways - really should be in the mix, and not to get there is an abject failure.


RE: Darren Moore future poll. - SW4Baggie - 03-02-2019

(03-02-2019, 11:28 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: I don’t see the point in sacking him during this campaign - to do that only sends out a message to any successor that only automatic promotion is acceptable; and that really isn’t a great prospect for any coach who will know that they may well be faced with further squad upheaval come summer.

There is an argument that there is time for one last push with an experienced expert at the helm, but there is no guarantee either that anyone suitable is available; nor that they can actually do the job.

So, for me, it all depends upon where we end up in May. I think if we make the play-offs, then win-or-lose he deserves to be here for the curtain raiser in August. Although achievable, the top two was always going to be a tall order, and as said ad-nauseum most of us would have accepted play-offs back at the start of the season.

I think if we finish below 6th place then he probably has to go. This squad - although limited in some ways - really should be in the mix, and not to get there is an abject failure.

Fair post, however I think just top 6 alone shouldn’t be the barometer of success.

If we limp over the line with say a 6th place finish, picking up maybe 15 more points this season, Id question the point of keeping someone who demonstrated he can’t get the best out of a group of players.

If he finds a fix to our poor form, we hit another run and finish within 3-4 points of the top 2, then for me he deserves the opportunity next season.

The remaining 11 games are IMO his audition for whether he has the job beyond the summer.


RE: Darren Moore future poll. - wba13 - 03-02-2019

No poll needed Darren has made mistakes but show me someone who hasn’t . The man has turned this club around in the last ten months and deserves a good run at the job .Just look at Farke, Wilder and Johnson to name 3 who have been left to build there clubs and aren’t doing to bad. We are still fourth and there are a lot of stupid posts when we lose a couple of matches . You will get no scapegoating from me I will always be positive because I believe eventually and soon we will get it right.


RE: Darren Moore future poll. - Zak - 03-02-2019

We have a top 2 squad, Moore is not a top 2 manager. It is that simple.

Playoffs about right.


RE: Darren Moore future poll. - Shabby Russian - 03-02-2019

I went for the longest option, but not sure I saw much difference between that and the third option to be honest.

For me he is massively in credit, given where we were this time last season.

I think within the squad we have some very good players and one that should be challenging for promotion, which we have done to be fair.

There are criticisms made of Moore that just don't stand up to close scrutiny. Apparently his in game management is poor, but we have yet to lose a game this season where we scored first and have gained a good number of point from losing positions. My query would be why do we concede the first goal in so many matches?

Apparently he is tactically naïve, but no one ever goes on to explain why he is tactically naïve.

I'm not convinced by the current 433 formation, I don't think there is a combination of the 3 up top that works with the present squad, it did work adequately when Barnes was with us, but I think it is fair to say without him not so much.

What I would say is that perhaps the key personnel at the club is not the head coach and his coaching staff, but those who are responsible for recruitment. Because this is key, we need to have a more cohesive group of players. For example I do think at this level both Rodriguez and Gayle are good players, but I am far from convinced that they play well together.

I also believe that Moore might be the man to get the best out of the exciting crop of new talent we have coming through the club. By and large he is handling the younger players, as I said elsewhere last night was one too many games in a row for Harper, but overall he is dong a grand job with the young players.