WBAUnofficial
How have we got here? Part 5 - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: How have we got here? Part 5 (/showthread.php?tid=24819)

Pages: 1 2


How have we got here? Part 5 - petty sniper - 04-04-2022

My opinions on where we are at.

Val was doing OK, but was finding it difficult to get some of the loud voices in the club to buy into his methods.  By that I mean the more senior players and many fans.

We had a team that didnt look like conceding and didnt look like taking the chances it created.

Most of the squad started well and followed his very simple instructions but gradually they found it maybe too tough and gave up.

This tit Gouraly if he had any ounce of caring for the club should have acted sooner, maybe in october to support Val, identify the players who were not performing and help him sort it.  Instead he waited for Val to become a walking p45, played his hand and got a job for his mate.

I have nothing against Bruce but the club needs a reset.  It doesnt need safe hands or steadying, we need someone to come in and shake it up.  Get the players who have ability to put in a shift and start turning things around - it can be done but it so obvious it aint bruce. 

Take the example of Grant who contrary to the opinion of many, worked his socks off in the left of a three, covered as much ground as anyone and was always looking for the ball.  Now I bet his kit dont even need washing.

If I was in charge I would try to get Mowbray with Scott Brown as player assistant.  He would sort some of the slackers out because the fabled rebuild is a few years away yet, we need to get a tune out of what we have


RE: How have we got here? Part 5 - Dumbo - 04-04-2022

You lose any credibility saying we should sign Scott Brown as a player.


RE: How have we got here? Part 5 - SW4Baggie - 04-04-2022

The simple fact is, we are not going to get anything out of the vast majority of this group

They liked Slav because he was their best mate and training was a doss, however they had the best player in the division by a country mile in Pereira, and Grady was out to impress West Ham which carried what was ultimately a load of fair weather players over the line - even though they did their utmost to blow it. As much as I disliked what we were paying him, Austin was also a decent shithouse to have around the place.

The only way we are going to get a tune out of this lot is if we make it piss easy for them again, by signing the type of quality that will drag them over the line… and we just aren’t going to do that.

We’ve tried the disciplinarian, we’ve tried the best pals act, and neither have worked. The only time we looked remotely like a decent side was when we replaced half the squad with expensive loanees for a handful of games last year, and it took one of those to call them out as unprofessional to get a modicum of a reaction.

We’ve got some way to go before this turns round, regardless of who is in the dugout.


RE: How have we got here? Part 5 - Beachboysbaggie - 04-04-2022

You can talk about managers, systems, transfer activity all you like but for me the biggest reason by far for our failure is the collective form of Grant, Diangana and Robinson. That’s - based on what we paid - 43m of talent. If we’d seen the Robinson of Stamford Bridge, the Grady of 19/20 and the Grant of his first couple of seasons at Huddersfield we’d be promoted already, regardless of who was in charge or how much we sold Pereira for, etc. Even if they’d lived up to half of that we’d be playoffs. They’ve just been unbelievably bad, and yes I know Grant’s scored a few but he’s arguably the worst of the three. 
I refuse to believe they aren’t capable of hitting those heights again, I’ve just no idea how it can be made to happen


RE: How have we got here? Part 5 - Tom Joad - 04-04-2022

SW4Baggie Wrote:The simple fact is, we are not going to get anything out of the vast majority of this group

They liked Slav because he was their best mate and training was a doss, however they had the best player in the division by a country mile in Pereira, and Grady was out to impress West Ham which carried what was ultimately a load of fair weather players over the line - even though they did their utmost to blow it. As much as I disliked what we were paying him, Austin was also a decent shithouse to have around the place.

The only way we are going to get a tune out of this lot is if we make it piss easy for them again, by signing the type of quality that will drag them over the line… and we just aren’t going to do that.

We’ve tried the disciplinarian, we’ve tried the best pals act, and neither have worked. The only time we looked remotely like a decent side was when we replaced half the squad with expensive loanees for a handful of games last year, and it took one of those to call them out as unprofessional to get a modicum of a reaction.

We’ve got some way to go before this turns round, regardless of who is in the dugout.
Good post SW. Without wanting to re-start the Val v Bruce argument, I wish the club had come out  and backed Ishmael, even assisted him in bombing out the slackers. Of course, with a negative net spend we didn't have the squad resources to do so and the crowd would not have had the patience to wait for things to improve. Val may well have been the right man, but with no backing it was most definitely the wrong time. Bruce may well be exactly the same. We need a Megson, a Fergie, a Wile and Big Ron combo to bost a few heads, but ultimately until the hierarchy at the club take responsibility for their appointments, we are doomed to repeat the same mistakes.


RE: How have we got here? Part 5 - Hughie Reed 31 - 04-04-2022

(04-04-2022, 05:18 PM)Dumbo Wrote: You lose any credibility saying we should sign Scott Brown as a player.

You might not like when petty sniper mention Scott Brown name but he’s got a winners mentally
Something that none of our present players seem to possess.


RE: How have we got here? Part 5 - TETLEY74 - 04-04-2022

(04-04-2022, 06:26 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
SW4Baggie Wrote:The simple fact is, we are not going to get anything out of the vast majority of this group

They liked Slav because he was their best mate and training was a doss, however they had the best player in the division by a country mile in Pereira, and Grady was out to impress West Ham which carried what was ultimately a load of fair weather players over the line - even though they did their utmost to blow it. As much as I disliked what we were paying him, Austin was also a decent shithouse to have around the place.

The only way we are going to get a tune out of this lot is if we make it piss easy for them again, by signing the type of quality that will drag them over the line… and we just aren’t going to do that.

We’ve tried the disciplinarian, we’ve tried the best pals act, and neither have worked. The only time we looked remotely like a decent side was when we replaced half the squad with expensive loanees for a handful of games last year, and it took one of those to call them out as unprofessional to get a modicum of a reaction.

We’ve got some way to go before this turns round, regardless of who is in the dugout.
Good post SW. Without wanting to re-start the Val v Bruce argument, I wish the club had come out  and backed Ishmael, even assisted him in bombing out the slackers. Of course, with a negative net spend we didn't have the squad resources to do so and the crowd would not have had the patience to wait for things to improve. Val may well have been the right man, but with no backing it was most definitely the wrong time. Bruce may well be exactly the same. We need a Megson, a Fergie, a Wile and Big Ron combo to bost a few heads, but ultimately until the hierarchy at the club take responsibility for their appointments, we are doomed to repeat the same mistakes.
Absolutely this well said mon.


RE: How have we got here? Part 5 - SW4Baggie - 04-04-2022

(04-04-2022, 06:44 PM)Hughie Reed 31 Wrote:
(04-04-2022, 05:18 PM)Dumbo Wrote: You lose any credibility saying we should sign Scott Brown as a player.

You might not like when petty sniper mention Scott Brown name but he’s got a winners mentally
Something that none of our present players seem to possess.

He’s also 36 and never played above League One


RE: How have we got here? Part 5 - Midget In A Pinstripe Suit - 04-04-2022

(04-04-2022, 06:59 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-04-2022, 06:44 PM)Hughie Reed 31 Wrote:
(04-04-2022, 05:18 PM)Dumbo Wrote: You lose any credibility saying we should sign Scott Brown as a player.

You might not like when petty sniper mention Scott Brown name but he’s got a winners mentally
Something that none of our present players seem to possess.

He’s also 36 and never played above League One

That’s something me and him have in common. Wink


RE: How have we got here? Part 5 - Cuzer - 04-04-2022

(04-04-2022, 06:26 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
SW4Baggie Wrote:The simple fact is, we are not going to get anything out of the vast majority of this group

They liked Slav because he was their best mate and training was a doss, however they had the best player in the division by a country mile in Pereira, and Grady was out to impress West Ham which carried what was ultimately a load of fair weather players over the line - even though they did their utmost to blow it. As much as I disliked what we were paying him, Austin was also a decent shithouse to have around the place.

The only way we are going to get a tune out of this lot is if we make it piss easy for them again, by signing the type of quality that will drag them over the line… and we just aren’t going to do that.

We’ve tried the disciplinarian, we’ve tried the best pals act, and neither have worked. The only time we looked remotely like a decent side was when we replaced half the squad with expensive loanees for a handful of games last year, and it took one of those to call them out as unprofessional to get a modicum of a reaction.

We’ve got some way to go before this turns round, regardless of who is in the dugout.
Good post SW. Without wanting to re-start the Val v Bruce argument, I wish the club had come out  and backed Ishmael, even assisted him in bombing out the slackers. Of course, with a negative net spend we didn't have the squad resources to do so and the crowd would not have had the patience to wait for things to improve. Val may well have been the right man, but with no backing it was most definitely the wrong time. Bruce may well be exactly the same. We need a Megson, a Fergie, a Wile and Big Ron combo to bost a few heads, but ultimately until the hierarchy at the club take responsibility for their appointments, we are doomed to repeat the same mistakes.

It’s easy to say in hindsight but I’ve not said it in hindsight, I’ve said it all along but all it needed was a club statement of backing and intent from the board In Jan, a couple of player interviews backing the management and everybody, fans included, would have knuckled down for the rest of the season knowing this was our plan

Val made us extremely solid and we did create chances, just not as clear as we needed to but it was hardly his fault Hugill was dogshit and Dike got injured, hence my belief he would have steadied the ship and kept us around the play offs at least 

Now, we can’t attack, can’t defend and have no idea what sort of side we are….besides a piss poor one

Cuzer