WBAUnofficial
Unpopular opinion - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Unpopular opinion (/showthread.php?tid=24475)

Pages: 1 2


Unpopular opinion - Dumbo - 03-05-2022

We look a better team without Andy Carroll.

That’s nothing against the big man himself, and certainly nothing against his effort and endeavour….but the team has less tendency to hit aimless balls forward without the big man up there. 

Until Dike is fit, this is the team that should be playing. TGH and Livermore were massive in the middle. Grant and Robbo up top.


RE: Unpopular opinion - Cornflake - 03-05-2022

(03-05-2022, 05:48 PM)Dumbo Wrote: We look a better team without Andy Carroll.

That’s nothing against the big man himself, and certainly nothing against his effort and endeavour….but the team has less tendency to hit aimless balls forward without the big man up there. 

Until Dike is fit, this is the team that should be playing. TGH and Livermore were massive in the middle. Grant and Robbo up top.

Not unpopular at all


RE: Unpopular opinion - Sliced - 03-05-2022

Unfortunately it’s true. Much like with Shane Long at the end of his stay here, playing Carroll makes the others lazier because rather than having to pick a pass they can lump it forward. Grant and Robinson need the ball on the ground more.


RE: Unpopular opinion - Shabby Russian - 03-05-2022

I've been a little surprised by comments on Carroll's performances.

For me he has been a solid 6 in most games he has played. 

I don't think we have the players to bring the best out if him and not sure his injury history and goal scoring record demands a squad being built round him.

His attitude has been spot on, but we need more than that to justify him being here next season


RE: Unpopular opinion - Brandywell - 03-05-2022

Totally agree, can't fault his effort but he's just not mobile enough

Couple of times in the last game we broke away went to put a ball in the box and he was still making his way there

Hopefully when Dike is back it'll be the last we see of him


RE: Unpopular opinion - Cunninghamismagic - 03-05-2022

Useful player to have though. Held the ball up well when he came on with a couple of decent lay offs


RE: Unpopular opinion - Hopalong - 03-05-2022

(03-05-2022, 05:57 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I've been a little surprised by comments on Carroll's performances.

For me he has been a solid 6 in most games he has played. 

I don't think we have the players to bring the best out if him and not sure his injury history and goal scoring record demands a squad being built round him.

His attitude has been spot on, but we need more than that to justify him being here next season

Andy is a great addition in all the circumstances, will always give his all and was great when he came on when we needed some experience to see the game out.


RE: Unpopular opinion - HugeHons - 03-05-2022

We were lumping it forward long before Andy Carroll arrived


RE: Unpopular opinion - HawkingsHalfpint - 03-05-2022

As well as he played, I did start to wonder if he just wasn’t quite mobile enough given the lack of creativity in midfield. With a decent number 10 he’d have probably made a lot more impact than the albeit positive impact he did.

That being said, using inverted wingers while he was in the side was just plain saft.


RE: Unpopular opinion - Fido - 03-05-2022

(03-05-2022, 06:17 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: As well as he played, I did start to wonder if he just wasn’t quite mobile enough given the lack of creativity in midfield. With a decent number 10 he’d have probably made a lot more impact than the albeit positive impact he did.

That being said, using inverted wingers while he was in the side was just plain saft.

This.