WBAUnofficial
Manager quandary - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Manager quandary (/showthread.php?tid=23901)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


Manager quandary - JOK - 01-31-2022

Can someone give an answer to this conundrum please?
 
I often read on here of concerns about us not having any ‘football knowledge’ on the board, or we haven’t had a ‘decent’ Director of Football since Ashworth. Indeed, this is raised again in the current thread ‘Imminent Sacking’.
 
Yet, when every ex footballing pundit and football person currently in the game discusses this, almost to a man, say managers need two or three seasons to build a successful team or one that can compete.
 
So, here’s the rub, we want a ‘football brain’ on the board but football people believe in giving time to new managers (so they always recon) but we are also regularly calling for managers to be shown the door within a season. Seven months-ish in this case.
So, do we want that ‘football man’ upstairs, who’s inclination would be to have patience, or do we want continual knee jerk sackings of managers?
 
(Yes, I know things are more convoluted than black and white choices, with finances / crowds/ style of play etc. to be considered. I can’t comment on today’s style of play as I’ve not seen it at the ground but I sat through every home game of Pulis’s reign and surely it can’t be any worse than that)


RE: Manager quandary - Derek Hardballs - 01-31-2022

Our only advantage as a club is the parachute payments in the Championship. Three year projects with a small pot of cash distributed over three years (if that is true) isn’t going to make us imo competitive over the clubs coming down or those who have owners willing to invest already in the league. Giving managers time is a noble route to take but it doesn’t mean it will yield anymore success. Also the way we are operating currently means if Val leaves be it if he gets the sack or does well and gets poached we are currently left with a very flimsy football department.

Currently we have entrusted Val with our future for the next 1- 3 / 4 seasons.


RE: Manager quandary - Peachy - 01-31-2022

Yes but if a manager wants the luxury of being given 2 or 3 seasons to build his side then he needs to keep getting results and at the very least needs to showing signs of evolving into something that owners and fans can recognise.

We aren't doing that. Not only aren't we doing it but we are actually going in the other direction. We are regressing at some speed. Every player under Vals methods is getting worse.

We are a far worse team than the sum of our parts. This is all on the manager and his myopic "philosophy".


RE: Manager quandary - Sliced - 01-31-2022

(01-31-2022, 10:30 AM)Peachy Wrote: Yes but if a manager wants the luxury of being given 2 or 3 seasons to build his side then he needs to keep getting results and at the very least needs to showing signs of evolving into something that owners and fans can recognise.

We aren't doing that. Not only aren't we doing it but we are actually going in the other direction. We are regressing at some speed. Every player under Vals methods is getting worse.

We are a far worse team than the sum of our parts. This is all on the manager and his myopic "philosophy".

Agree, but this is only the case in recent weeks, and it doesn't look like changing.....so he has to go.

However, 5th with the players we currently have is unfortunately not terrible. I wish it were a case of a semi competent manager being able to lead this shower to promotion, but it's not. If the new man can turn us around then he deserves massive credit, regardless of who it is.


RE: Manager quandary - Spandaubaggie - 01-31-2022

Just wish to agree that our issue seems to be a solid footballing infrastructure.

The summer's business of messing about with Wilder, being teased by Wagner and ultimately giving a ridiculous contract to a manager with one season's success is the sign of a club needing a wise old head running it, ably assisted by the best accountancy advice.

What we did in the summer was unbelievably stupid.

Results we all could handle if we saw some kind of vision enveloping before us from someone with charisma, who could win us over.

I don't think any fans are being knee-jerk. He needs to go and we need to get some football brains into the club as well as a new coach.


RE: Manager quandary - Bob Fossil - 01-31-2022

(01-31-2022, 10:30 AM)Peachy Wrote: Yes but if a manager wants the luxury of being given 2 or 3 seasons to build his side then he needs to keep getting results and at the very least needs to showing signs of evolving into something that owners and fans can recognise.

We aren't doing that. Not only aren't we doing it but we are actually going in the other direction. We are regressing at some speed. Every player under Vals methods is getting worse.

We are a far worse team than the sum of our parts. This is all on the manager and his myopic "philosophy".

This should be the end of the conversation for me Peachy.
Some people are even blaming the fans now, it's our fault that there's a toxic atmosphere.
The truth is, however, that in my 40 odd years experience, we have fantastic fans, who will put up with anything as long as there is hope. Even after the 12 minute resurgence against Peterborough, my Whatsapp Baggies group, lit up with positivity for the Preston game, with everyone, 100% of them, believing we could had turned a corner. Then THAT performance happens. Back to the same old aimless, passionless, ultra-predictable dross of the last 2 months and that's what pushed most sane fans over the edge. Jump forward to Milwall and, despite Val's, latest, "epiphany" we get exactly the same, but now he's managed to convert the draws into defeats.

Val has taken away the hope. The hope that it is work in progress and will improve, the hope that, yet another new striker, will make the difference, the hope that he may tweak his tactics or formation.
Without hope a football fan is just an empty shell, and that is where Val has put us. There's no way back now for me.


RE: Manager quandary - MassDebater - 01-31-2022

A good, Ashworth style, DoF and we'd probably not be in this same situation. I think everyone realises how bad the behind the scenes stuff is, but we have no real direct influence on that, I guess we don't on the manager either, but empty seats and no ticket sales will probably say more to lai than any chants will.

As I've said elsewhere, it's all very well trying to plan for the future, but I honestly think that is a lot easier when you're a club with no parachutes, limited funds and very limited fan expectations, use Leeds as an example and the Bielsa project, much easier to buy into after several seasons in the wilderness. For me, promotion was needed this season, due to the finances, and if Six had achieved that (hey, he still could!! Big Grin Big Grin) then no-one would be calling for the sack. No plan survives enemy contact as they say.

If you put the wrong person in charge and it all goes tits up then no long term plan can ever be achieved. it is a catch 22, but tough decisions have to be made.

As for Pulis being worse, I honestly no longer think he was. I hated his football with a passion, but I honestly think that Six's version of it just sucks every ounce of enjoyment from the game, and at least Pulis was fighting to keep us up, rather than having one of the top squads in the division and really struggling to get us competing.


RE: Manager quandary - Spandaubaggie - 01-31-2022

(01-31-2022, 10:53 AM)MassDebater Wrote: A good, Ashworth style, DoF and we'd probably not be in this same situation. I think everyone realises how bad the behind the scenes stuff is, but we have no real direct influence on that, I guess we don't on the manager either, but empty seats and no ticket sales will probably say more to lai than any chants will.

As I've said elsewhere, it's all very well trying to plan for the future, but I honestly think that is a lot easier when you're a club with no parachutes, limited funds and very limited fan expectations, use Leeds as an example and the Bielsa project, much easier to buy into after several seasons in the wilderness. For me, promotion was needed this season, due to the finances, and if Six had achieved that (hey, he still could!! Big Grin Big Grin) then no-one would be calling for the sack. No plan survives enemy contact as they say.

If you put the wrong person in charge and it all goes tits up then no long term plan can ever be achieved. it is a catch 22, but tough decisions have to be made.

As for Pulis being worse, I honestly no longer think he was. I hated his football with a passion, but I honestly think that Six's version of it just sucks every ounce of enjoyment from the game, and at least Pulis was fighting to keep us up, rather than having one of the top squads in the division and really struggling to get us competing.
You've summed it up pretty well there.

We looked good for a couple of months, but there was restlessness at displays long before the wheels came off. The drudgery of dull wins over Blues and Hull were accepted and somehow many of us, myself included, thought he must have it on the right lines as we were up there, but just needed tweaking to make us more efficient.

Instead the wheels have come right off and we've all completely lost faith in him. More importantly it seems the players have too.

We do need to invest in a long-term project though and this is an aside from the current crisis. I would hope those in charge look for the best brains and clubs doing it the right way. If they don't they'll never see their £100m back.


RE: Manager quandary - DemonicBaggie - 01-31-2022

(01-31-2022, 10:46 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Without hope a football fan is just an empty shell, and that is where Val has put us. 

Are you by any chance a trilobite?


RE: Manager quandary - Bob Fossil - 01-31-2022

(01-31-2022, 11:04 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(01-31-2022, 10:53 AM)MassDebater Wrote: A good, Ashworth style, DoF and we'd probably not be in this same situation. I think everyone realises how bad the behind the scenes stuff is, but we have no real direct influence on that, I guess we don't on the manager either, but empty seats and no ticket sales will probably say more to lai than any chants will.

As I've said elsewhere, it's all very well trying to plan for the future, but I honestly think that is a lot easier when you're a club with no parachutes, limited funds and very limited fan expectations, use Leeds as an example and the Bielsa project, much easier to buy into after several seasons in the wilderness. For me, promotion was needed this season, due to the finances, and if Six had achieved that (hey, he still could!! Big Grin Big Grin) then no-one would be calling for the sack. No plan survives enemy contact as they say.

If you put the wrong person in charge and it all goes tits up then no long term plan can ever be achieved. it is a catch 22, but tough decisions have to be made.

As for Pulis being worse, I honestly no longer think he was. I hated his football with a passion, but I honestly think that Six's version of it just sucks every ounce of enjoyment from the game, and at least Pulis was fighting to keep us up, rather than having one of the top squads in the division and really struggling to get us competing.
You've summed it up pretty well there.

We looked good for a couple of months, but there was restlessness at displays long before the wheels came off. The drudgery of dull wins over Blues and Hull were accepted and somehow many of us, myself included, thought he must have it on the right lines as we were up there, but just needed tweaking to make us more efficient.

Instead the wheels have come right off and we've all completely lost faith in him. More importantly it seems the players have too.

We do need to invest in a long-term project though and this is an aside from the current crisis. I would hope those in charge look for the best brains and clubs doing it the right way. If they don't they'll never see their £100m back.
I agree re the DoF as it's the only way we can genuinely look long term. Managers will come and go as, successful ones will get poached and unsuccessful ones will get sacked, so, if it's about a philosophy, we need a DoF to hold it all together so that we are continually recruiting the right type of player and manager alike.

Even this model is flawed for a club like us though because, as seen with Ashworth, any DoF who does well will also be primed for approach.

What we can't do is let a failing project continue out of pride or blind faith, as the further we drop, the harder it is to come back.
People forget that we still have the massive advantage of parachute payments and, as much as it pains me to say it, we can't afford to let that slip.