![]() |
|
Is our problem purely the front line decision making? - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Is our problem purely the front line decision making? (/showthread.php?tid=23600) |
Is our problem purely the front line decision making? - Spandaubaggie - 01-19-2022 Said on another post, but worthy of a post on its own to debate. The stats have shown us dominate games, but in the final 3rd the decision making and final ball has been woeful. We've seen games we dominate and yet fail to score as someone like Reach punts a cross flying 12 feet high as it crosses the penalty box. Also the lack of bodies in the box, where there's only 2 guys in there as the cross comes over. I'm beginning to think this is the case. Thoughts? RE: Is our problem purely the front line decision making? - Jacobthebaggie - 01-19-2022 It's that fuckin' Livermore. Close thread RE: Is our problem purely the front line decision making? - WorcsWBA - 01-19-2022 (01-19-2022, 10:25 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Said on another post, but worthy of a post on its own to debate. The stats have shown us dominate games, but in the final 3rd the decision making and final ball has been woeful. The passing/composure in the final third is certainly sub-standard, except for a handful of games where it clicked (e.g. Sheff U, Cardiff, Bristol C). As for the number of players in the box, I remember watching videos explaining Val's playing style when he was first appointed and the 3 forwards are supposed to play quite close to each other, so we should generally have at least 3 players in the box when a cross is about to come in. One of the wing-backs should be trying to get in there too and, unless both wing-backs are forward, a central midfielder shouldn't be far away either. Ultimately, though, if players aren't doing their jobs properly, someone else should be tried in that position. Injuries and suspensions haven't been helping that of late of course. RE: Is our problem purely the front line decision making? - Sliced - 01-19-2022 That's a major part, however the buck doesn't stop with the front three. The wing backs and central midfielders should be doing better in the final third as well. For whatever reason our decision making in the attacking third hasn't been good, and our finishing has been even worse. This is primarily due to the players we have not fitting in well with the current system. However, if it's clear that we're lacking in the final and our crossing is horrendous then we need to play a big more narrow. How do we do that? Add another central body to provide support. Where does that extra body come from? At the expense of one of our three centre backs. The players should be doing better in the current system, but if it's not working then the manager has to change the system; which he hasn't done even once. When all is said and done it doesn't matter whether we're dominating or not, the results matter. RE: Is our problem purely the front line decision making? - Spandaubaggie - 01-19-2022 (01-19-2022, 10:43 AM)Sliced Wrote: That's a major part, however the buck doesn't stop with the front three. The wing backs and central midfielders should be doing better in the final third as well. For whatever reason our decision making in the attacking third hasn't been good, and our finishing has been even worse. This is primarily due to the players we have not fitting in well with the current system. There has to be a system and process in anything to get results. My hope is Dike makes enough of a nuisance of himself to free space for others, who may feel more confident to venture those few extra yards forward and find the ball at their feet creating real chances, which to me mean ones where you might score. There's a world of difference between a 25 yard shot harmlessly flying wide and a 15 yard chance where the defence has been sliced wide open. RE: Is our problem purely the front line decision making? - Bob Fossil - 01-19-2022 You have to look at the system as a whole for me. We have decent forwards, who have all scored goals at this level. Grant, Robinson, Diangana, Phillips and even Hugill. Yet no combination seems to work. We have decent crossers, Reach, Townsend, Phillips, Furlong, yet no combination seems to work. We have decent set piece specialists, Mowatt, Reach, TGH, Phillips, Furlong (throws anyway) even Snodgrass taking, Bartley, Kipre, Clarke, Ajayi, Hugill on the receiving end, yet even this no longer pays dividends. There's just too much that's not working to simply blame the players. IMO RE: Is our problem purely the front line decision making? - Spandaubaggie - 01-19-2022 (01-19-2022, 11:08 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: You have to look at the system as a whole for me.But maybe then Bob you have to look at the incredible injuries/suspensions we've had? I'm inclined to think it's the system is fine, and you can say what you like but some of the crossing by our decent crossers at QPR were pub league standard. Reach was particularly woeful. Maybe we need players who can adapt to this? RE: Is our problem purely the front line decision making? - Hopalong - 01-19-2022 (01-19-2022, 10:25 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Said on another post, but worthy of a post on its own to debate. The stats have shown us dominate games, but in the final 3rd the decision making and final ball has been woeful. It's one of two things or in our case at the moment, both!; either the crosses are aimless - too far ahead of the on-rushing (lol) players or behind the front players or they are not in the right positions and not anticipating when the ball comes in. That's why we're not creating 'clear-cut' chances - watch the movement of Liverpool's front three - they find space through their movement and players are invariably running onto the ball to score, ours rarely are. Plus as is often overlooked teams are doing a number on us and our front three are tightly marked/crowded out. As has been suggested, certainly at home we should try Phillips and Diangana on Sat as wing-backs but it will probably be same old, same old. Val really has got to shake things up and find 'solutions' as he keeps talking about. I personally think the crowd will turn in the next two games if we don't put in two convincing performances with two victories. RE: Is our problem purely the front line decision making? - westbromjack - 01-19-2022 (01-19-2022, 11:08 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: You have to look at the system as a whole for me. I would argue that this goes higher and deeper. Since Lai came in to the club late in 2016, decision making has been poor and the level/quality of football we have witnessed in 5+ years has been some of the worst I have seen at the club. Appointments of John Williams As CEO led to hiring Alan Pardew as manager, a period post Tony Pulis that produced 3 wins in 21 games. Darren Moore’s appointment lifted the crowd and with Bilic came hope of a resurgence, but it was short lived. The appointment of Val came off the back of one of the worst decisions to date; the last minute u-turn on appointing Chris Wilder, who I believe could have restored the glory days to the club. After Pulis and Pardew, Valball is driving fans away from he club again. There is no atmosphere, no expectancy and we are long bereft of any boing. Not sure what’s going on for so many academy players to leave as Vals only endearing quality to me is the development of youth into the first team squad. Probably it is years of promise, but no execution. We are now wondering if we will even make the playoffs, where automatic promotion was the objective. We are resting hopes on Dike scoring goals, however the build up play referred to earlier in this post indicates that one player will not save the season. If we do not achieve promotion, I cannot see the fans supporting our current brand of football for another year. For me, it is an ownership issue. Owners pick the managers, managers pick the team and players play the style of football the manager wants or they are not selected. RE: Is our problem purely the front line decision making? - Bob Fossil - 01-19-2022 (01-19-2022, 11:18 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:It's not just QPR though, it goes way back and is not improving so, my question is, what are we doing in training to make decent forwards, decent crossers and decent set piece specialists, so bloody awful.(01-19-2022, 11:08 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: You have to look at the system as a whole for me.But maybe then Bob you have to look at the incredible injuries/suspensions we've had? This gets lost a bit in the "players just aren't good enough" rhetoric. Val is coaching them, Val is setting up the training sessions, Val is man-managing them, yet there is no sign of improvement. If that's not a key part of his job, and therefore something he should be judged on, what is? |