WBAUnofficial
Clear and Obvious - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Clear and Obvious (/showthread.php?tid=18641)

Pages: 1 2


Clear and Obvious - Shabby Russian - 06-16-2021

It's becoming clear and obvious that there is a far higher bar for what is considered a clear and obvious error at the Euros than in the Premier League.

This must be the way those who supported VAR thought it would be used. Even a sceptic like me could be converted, especially if there was a tweak to the offside rules.


RE: Clear and Obvious - Pedders - 06-16-2021

Yeah , agreed - had thought that myself. Back the ref, overturn if he has had an absolute shocker.

Some will still complain, like the Danish pen was v soft, but it feels a lot smoother and how it worked pretty well at the World Cup. VAR there to stop the big errors, not ruin the flow and the game.

Agreed on offside as well, although still not sure how you get away from those lines, as that is what offside is…maybe thicker lines?!

Wonder if the Prem is watching and learning


RE: Clear and Obvious - DJPunkRoc - 06-16-2021

(06-16-2021, 09:59 AM)Pedders Wrote: Yeah , agreed - had thought that myself. Back the ref, overturn if he has had an absolute shocker.

Some will still complain, like the Danish pen was v soft, but it feels a lot smoother and how it worked pretty well at the World Cup. VAR there to stop the big errors, not ruin the flow and the game.

Agreed on offside as well, although still not sure how you get away from those lines, as that is what offside is…maybe thicker lines?!

Wonder if the Prem is watching and learning

Maybe just where the attackers furthest forward foot is vs the defender's furthest back foot is.  How can an elbow be offside?

Agree with the obviously variable interpretation (and the Euros being better - the ref for Germany France was v good I thought) and, in fact from what I've seen, the standard of refereeing is heads and shoulders above the PL.  

Is there an English ref at the Euros?


RE: Clear and Obvious - Borin' Baggie - 06-16-2021

They've also increased the threshold for offsides, so marginal decisions give benefit of the doubt (margin of error due to hardware and human limitations) to the attacker. Nice that they've used common sense instead of spending 10 minutes to draw a line that might be wrong anyway as they've used the wrong frame.


RE: Clear and Obvious - boingingbaggie - 06-16-2021

They also seem to make the final decision much quicker. The Mbappe offside last night was decided in 30-45 secs. We've seen 2-3 minutes to decide on an offside.
I said all along it's not the technology that is the issue, it's the idiots who run it.
There's been 12 matches so far, other than the Swiss no goal against Wales and the Denmark penalty I can't really think of any other major decisions VAR has got wrong. Compare that to the Premier League where it was almost 1 per game.


RE: Clear and Obvious - wba13 - 06-16-2021

Yes Anthony Taylor was the English ref at the Erickson incident, did himself no harm at all handled the incident perfectly. Also put in very professional March performance.


RE: Clear and Obvious - Shabby Russian - 06-16-2021

I think I have seen a couple of on pitch decisions which were wrong, but not overturned. Denmark penalty, tackle on Mbappe by Hummels last night should have been a penalty, but I am happy they went with pitch refs original decision.

On offside I would like to see a rule that VAR cannot overrule a goal if any part of forwards body is level with last defender, you will still get lines drawn, but I think it will feel less unjust.


RE: Clear and Obvious - clem4england - 06-16-2021

Absolutely spot on. It's like chalk and cheese and each game hasn't been ruined by delays, nonsensical decisions etc.


RE: Clear and Obvious - Rustynail - 06-16-2021

Would love to see the linesperson actually raise the flag when the forward is clearly offside, at the moment the offside occurs not several minutes later as is the fashion these days.


RE: Clear and Obvious - Borin' Baggie - 06-16-2021

(06-16-2021, 11:01 AM)Rustynail Wrote: Would love to see the linesperson actually raise the flag when the forward is clearly offside, at the moment the offside occurs not several minutes later as is the fashion these days.

Issue is that raising the flag can cause interference with play, which could in turn affect how play is carried out if the linesman is wrong.

We saw it when we played Man City, linesman flagged too early and our players just stopped and let them score.