![]() |
|
Relegation and promotion rigidity - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Relegation and promotion rigidity (/showthread.php?tid=17667) Pages:
1
2
|
Relegation and promotion rigidity - Spandaubaggie - 05-19-2021 With Bournemouth having the edge in their play-off there's a decent chance that all 3 clubs that went down last season are on the way back, plus 2 of the 3 who went up have gone down. It's always been tough for clubs going up and the parachute makes it easier for those going down, but is this season a new level of predictability? Next year I think we are in a stronger position than when we went down in 2018 due to the way many Championship clubs have suffered more than us due to revenue during the pandemic. Regardless of who is manager I'd be shocked if we don't come straight back. RE: Relegation and promotion rigidity - Pragmatist - 05-19-2021 (05-19-2021, 08:37 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: With Bournemouth having the edge in their play-off there's a decent chance that all 3 clubs that went down last season are on the way back, plus 2 of the 3 who went up have gone down. It merely highlights the growing gulf between the two divisions. Clubs not quite good enough for the PL but too good for the Championship Sadly I think it increases the risk of parachute payments being attacked, which would be very dangerous as they are there to stop relegated teams going bankrupt. The only alternative is to close the funding gap between the two divisions and its very hard to see that happening. RE: Relegation and promotion rigidity - Spandaubaggie - 05-19-2021 (05-19-2021, 08:41 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:(05-19-2021, 08:37 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: With Bournemouth having the edge in their play-off there's a decent chance that all 3 clubs that went down last season are on the way back, plus 2 of the 3 who went up have gone down. I really wish they would close the financial gap between the two divisions as it'd massively help all in the Championship and prevent some of the financial disasters we've seen with clubs like Pompey and Bolton. RE: Relegation and promotion rigidity - baggy1 - 05-19-2021 (05-19-2021, 09:00 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:(05-19-2021, 08:41 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:(05-19-2021, 08:37 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: With Bournemouth having the edge in their play-off there's a decent chance that all 3 clubs that went down last season are on the way back, plus 2 of the 3 who went up have gone down. Pompey and Bolton were both self made financial disasters and Pompey won the FA Cup (at our expense) on their complete overspending and fantasy budgeting. They have themselves to blame and the only reason they get some grace from me is the great escape day (so we are even now) RE: Relegation and promotion rigidity - SW4Baggie - 05-19-2021 (05-19-2021, 09:08 AM)baggy1 Wrote:(05-19-2021, 09:00 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:(05-19-2021, 08:41 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:(05-19-2021, 08:37 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: With Bournemouth having the edge in their play-off there's a decent chance that all 3 clubs that went down last season are on the way back, plus 2 of the 3 who went up have gone down. Completely agree. If the financial gap is closed between the Champ and PL it has to be with a focus to making it a more level playing field and to improve the competitiveness of the pyramid, not to encourage reckless financial mismanagement by owners. Generally COVID aside, any club that goes to the wall is due to mismanagement and paying players wages that were not sustainable. These were active decisions made by owners to gain an advantage over clubs who were doing things the right way and losing out. In order for teams to be competitive in the PL and to retain the integrity of the division promoted clubs need to invest in their squad hence the need for parachute payments. If they were to be removed it would pretty much guarantee relegation for every promoted side as very few would take the financial risks needed with the knowledge they’d return tk Champ revenues should the drop without support... wouldn’t be shocked if the lower midtable clubs voted for it, it would pretty much make the PL a closed shop with 3 new whipping boys annually. RE: Relegation and promotion rigidity - MGalea - 05-19-2021 The lower mid table clubs would be quite foolish to vote for it. As we saw in that season with Pulis/Pardew - we thought we had our best squad ever but still went down quite easily. The teams going up and being whipping boys can always stash the prem payments ala Norwich and probably still be good enough to get up again. If you are a prem club who think it's a closed shop and drop down with a sqaud low on morale / some key injuries and no flex down you could find yourselves being ruined within a couple of seasons. Can't imagine Brighton / Burnley / Newcastle(currently) / Palace / Southampton being too keen on taking the gamble they could slip down a division with giant wage bills and nothing to cover the revenue cut.. Equally what difference does it really make to City, Chelsea, Leicester? RE: Relegation and promotion rigidity - Shabby Russian - 05-19-2021 (05-19-2021, 08:37 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: With Bournemouth having the edge in their play-off there's a decent chance that all 3 clubs that went down last season are on the way back, plus 2 of the 3 who went up have gone down. I wouldn't be shocked if we didn't come straight back up. At the moment I have no certainty over who our manager will be next season or what the squad will look like. So impossible to make a judgement call. We should be in a stronger position than most of our rivals, but we can easily throw away any advantages we should have with bad decision making. RE: Relegation and promotion rigidity - SW4Baggie - 05-19-2021 (05-19-2021, 10:29 AM)MGalea Wrote: The lower mid table clubs would be quite foolish to vote for it. I mean you say we went down easily, we were absolute garbage for 75% of that season yet had we beaten Huddersfield at home we’d have survived. With the compound additional funds you’d have over and above every relegated side it would take something spectacular to go down! RE: Relegation and promotion rigidity - Stevel Knievel - 05-19-2021 (05-19-2021, 08:37 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: With Bournemouth having the edge in their play-off there's a decent chance that all 3 clubs that went down last season are on the way back, plus 2 of the 3 who went up have gone down. I don’t share the complacency. We’re going down with Fulham & Sheff Utd who will both be strong next year. At least one of the relegated teams will not make the top 2 and may make the play offs at which case it’s a bit of a lottery, as we have proven a couple of times in the past RE: Relegation and promotion rigidity - MGalea - 05-19-2021 SW4Baggie I mean you say we went down easily, we were absolute garbage for 75% of that season yet had we beaten Huddersfield at home we’d have survived. With the compound additional funds you’d have over and above every relegated side it would take something spectacular to go down! --- ------ ------ ------ ------ ------ ------ ------ --- Sheffield United are a great example of it both ways. When they came up nobody thought they stood a chance and they smashed it. At the start of this season you'd have said they'd have to really fuck it up to go down - let alone finish bottom - and they managed to really fuck it up! Thinking back through the seasons this has happened quite a few times... Bradford stayed up ffs! Ipswich went straight to Europe and back down.. It's most definitely a money league but look at the mess at Palace this summer - they might come back better than ever or they could have a brand new squad that just doesn't gel. Equally when you go down it may look easy with loads of money but there have been plenty of sqauds "too strong for the Championship" that have managed to finish in the bottom half and so on. It is all about the money but there will always be exceptions to the Wage Table/Transfer Spending league table. Can the lower Prem teams risk oblivion that way? |