![]() |
|
Our greatly improved side - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Our greatly improved side (/showthread.php?tid=17233) |
Our greatly improved side - Spandaubaggie - 05-04-2021 Managers always divide opinion. However, somethings are beyond argument as solid facts back them up. Firstly, saying this I'm not a fan of Allardyce - I didn't want him here, I probably won't be sad when he goes, but I can't deny he's made us better. The only thing you can beat him with is it took too long for us to finally get competitive, after some truly appalling displays when he first took over. Yet, you could argue perhaps what he'd been left with after the Bilic era was just too poor to work with? Simply as soon as the window closed we became a better side. The guys he brought in has transformed us. If the league had started when the new guys came in we'd be mid table. We can bemoan things like not beating Newcastle and Wolves, and not holding on v Villa, but depending on how far you want to go back with the end of the window a starting point, he's turned us into a competitive mid table side. To have got the points we need after then to stay up, take those dropped points, he'd have had to turn us into a side going from relegation into one going for the Champions League. To improve that much would have been the stuff of miracles. Also it's not helped that the team finishing 17th will have several points more than in most seasons. Simply, we may not have got the new manager bounce as the side was too poor to bounce with and as he watching us getting brushed aside he worked out what was needed- got them in and fixed it. We have been rubbish this season and for two thirds of it had a side as bad as I've ever seen at this level, going back 45 years. 1986's record looking possible to beat for a long while. Now we're going down with some respect restored. Based on the above, I find what he has done quite decent. The momentum is on the up. Each to their own, but I'd find it quite puzzling wanting to sack him based on the above, and as I said, I'm not a huge fan of him as a person. RE: Our greatly improved side - Cuzer - 05-04-2021 The problem with judging as per the above is Slav would have improved us in the Jan window, chances are Okay would have come in as he was always on the radar, probably Mbayye too, AMN was one not planned for so it's difficult Yes, we look a lot more competitive now, but I think we always were going to be post Jan window, not many sides come out of the Jan window weaker - although we managed it under Pepe Mel but that's another story Bottom line is we haven't been good enough, something we all feared when the season kicked off, nobody thought we would be top 10 but our lack of goals and inability to shoot ourselves in the foot defensively on a consistent basis has hit us hard, we've had a few highs, at times played some good stuff and then had a few stinkers, Fulham & Saints Away, Villa and Leeds at Home, Leicester away etc Just whether we reboot with a fresh approach or stick with Sam? Cuzer RE: Our greatly improved side - Spandaubaggie - 05-04-2021 (05-04-2021, 08:58 AM)Cuzer Wrote: The problem with judging as per the above is Slav would have improved us in the Jan window, chances are Okay would have come in as he was always on the radar, probably Mbayye too, AMN was one not planned for so it's difficult Good points. However, it's hypothetical if Slav's reinforcements would have been strong enough. Sheff U don't seem any better after Jan. I was all for doing a Norwich, but the word was Bilic wouldn't have stayed anyhow. Allardyce knows his onions and the football isn't been as bad as some would have made out. I'm for his staying based on this. RE: Our greatly improved side - Spandaubaggie - 05-04-2021 (05-04-2021, 09:12 AM)Mayo Wrote: Allardyce may be the best option we have at the moment but it is not right imo to praise him when we appear to be getting relegated when he was brought in to stop that - it is a failure and blaming the previous manager does not wash. Nor is it right imo to demonise Bilic who was brought in to get us promotion and succeeded in doing so (early according to some reports). The relegation is Sam's and the appalling start he had - the opposite to a bounce, what you want with a new manager - is a big part of that. If he'd got the bounce and/ or then gone on to keep us up, his success (and all hope is not quite gone) but it is foolish to ignore this is his failure and not question if other options may exist, assuming we drop. If he stays though it may be a good sign that he will be backed squadwise, else I think he'd walk. I find some lambasting Bilic harsh, as he did get us promoted. I have to admit too, he was an extremely likeable manager, which won me over as well. It all went wrong once we were up for him and I felt sad for him as he's a nice guy. I'm still grateful for what he did. Back onto Allardyce though, it's opinions and perhaps we were just too poor, but is that making excuses. I have to say those games around New Year were the worst batch of performances I ever recall- Leeds the standout, with our worst own goal of all time starting off our worst display I recall. That aside I've moved on. Three teams have to go down and we are unfortunate in that even if we'd improved a shade earlier its unlikely to be enough. I expect whoever finished 17th to have the highest points total in that position for many years. RE: Our greatly improved side - Selly Oak Albion - 05-04-2021 Big Sam needs to stay to continue his work. He may not be everyone's cup of tea, but he knows what he is doing. He will also attract better players. Oddly, I think people are resigned to this and are not that unhappy at the prospect. I always enjoyed the Championship more anyway. RE: Our greatly improved side - wba13 - 05-04-2021 (05-04-2021, 08:54 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Managers always divide opinion.Thank you Spandau, you have put into words what I’ve been thinking. I also am not an fan of Sam as a person but he has done an excellent job with no money. For me we keep, let him have the summer window and make this his team he deserves the chance. (05-04-2021, 09:12 AM)Mayo Wrote: Allardyce may be the best option we have at the moment but it is not right imo to praise him when we appear to be getting relegated when he was brought in to stop that - it is a failure and blaming the previous manager does not wash. Nor is it right imo to demonise Bilic who was brought in to get us promotion and succeeded in doing so (early according to some reports). The relegation is Sam's and the appalling start he had - the opposite to a bounce, what you want with a new manager - is a big part of that. If he'd got the bounce and/ or then gone on to keep us up, his success (and all hope is not quite gone) but it is foolish to ignore this is his failure and not question if other options may exist, assuming we drop. If he stays though it may be a good sign that he will be backed squadwise, else I think he'd walk. I have no problem with Bilic I wanted him to stay but I was wrong. We can see by the winter transfer that Sam knows how to pick a player. I personally do not see it as a failure but a step up but that’s what these boards are for opinions. RE: Our greatly improved side - Derek Hardballs - 05-04-2021 (05-04-2021, 09:12 AM)Mayo Wrote: Allardyce may be the best option we have at the moment but it is not right imo to praise him when we appear to be getting relegated when he was brought in to stop that - it is a failure and blaming the previous manager does not wash. Nor is it right imo to demonise Bilic who was brought in to get us promotion and succeeded in doing so (early according to some reports). The relegation is Sam's and the appalling start he had - the opposite to a bounce, what you want with a new manager - is a big part of that. If he'd got the bounce and/ or then gone on to keep us up, his success (and all hope is not quite gone) but it is foolish to ignore this is his failure and not question if other options may exist, assuming we drop. If he stays though it may be a good sign that he will be backed squadwise, else I think he'd walk. The team we had at the start of the season simply wasn't good enough whoever was in charge it was obvious to most who watched us week in week out. We only became competitive after we strengthened the glaring weaknesses in the team in January 2021, those weaknesses had been evident since at least January 2020. Now we can all argue who was and wasn't to blame for not addressing those weaknesses but the bottom line is we went into the season with very disjointed squad that limped over the line to promotion with the addition of a geriatric central defender and a young Gallagher. Bilic failure to turn around poor form, a lack of fitness and making us very easy to play against does make him accountable for relegation every bit as much as Allardyce if not more if we are going down the blame game route. It's only since Allardyce has been afforded a transfer window have we looked remotely like competing. The argument that any manager would come in and make a failing Championship standard squad suddenly start picking up points regularly from the get-go is wishful thinking. It's taken a a transfer window and months of training to get the squad in a position to compete and the stats and points tally point to this. The biggest mistake Allardyce made was thinking he had enough time to turn the Titanic around to avoid the huge iceberg with relegation written on it. Sadly the whole season has been inevitably rearranging deckchairs around on the aforementioned ship. We have got much better at this but not enough to stop us sinking. That is not one person's fault but a team of people and perhaps it was just financial reality. Putting the blame at the door of the current captain and absolving the previous who put the crew together alongside Admiral Dowling isn't fair or accurate. Perhaps putting the blame at either door is wrong and it's simple economics that have dictated our relegation. RE: Our greatly improved side - Spandaubaggie - 05-04-2021 (05-04-2021, 09:45 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(05-04-2021, 09:12 AM)Mayo Wrote: Allardyce may be the best option we have at the moment but it is not right imo to praise him when we appear to be getting relegated when he was brought in to stop that - it is a failure and blaming the previous manager does not wash. Nor is it right imo to demonise Bilic who was brought in to get us promotion and succeeded in doing so (early according to some reports). The relegation is Sam's and the appalling start he had - the opposite to a bounce, what you want with a new manager - is a big part of that. If he'd got the bounce and/ or then gone on to keep us up, his success (and all hope is not quite gone) but it is foolish to ignore this is his failure and not question if other options may exist, assuming we drop. If he stays though it may be a good sign that he will be backed squadwise, else I think he'd walk. Good post. Three teams will always go down and generally one or two of them will be those who come up. Leeds have spent well and also have someone recognised as one of the world's leading coaches. RE: Our greatly improved side - coxy134 - 05-04-2021 Sam has improved us defensively. It took a while to do it so guessing the big problem was fitness also along with self confidence. Those issues were there last season towards the end so I doubt Bilic would ever have sorted it. Sam should have been the replacement for Pulis. RE: Our greatly improved side - Ted Maul - 05-04-2021 If true that Bilic was offered Yokuslu and Diagne in the summer and went after Krovinovic and Grant instead then he deserved the sack just for that. Given we're starting to resemble a functioning football team for the first time in 18 months, it would seem foolish to disrupt all that by changing managers. |