Football managers - Baggy Bruin - 04-26-2021
Take one example. Nottingham Forest.
It is now April 2021.
How many managers have they had in the last 10 years?
1. Billy Davies was sacked in June 2011
2. Steve McLaren then had the job until October 2011
3. Steve Cotterill then had the job until July 2012
4. Sean O’Driscoll then had the job until December 2012
5. Alex McLeish then had the job until February 2013
6. Billy Davies returned and had the job until March 2014
7. Gary Brazil took over until May 2014
8. Stuart Pearce had the job until February 2015
9. Dougie Freedman had the job until March 2016
10. Paul Williams had the job until May 2016
11. Philip Montanier had the job until January 2017
12. Gary Brazil returned until March 2017
13. Mark Warburton had the job until December 2017
14. Aitor Karanka had the job until January 2019
15. Martin O’Neill had the job until June 2019
16. Sabri Lamouchi had the job until October 2020
and finally...
17. Chris Houghton is currently the manager of Nottingham Forest.
There is only one word to describe that, and it is SHAMBLES.
Back in the 1800s, through to the 1940s, football managers typically had their jobs for years, sometimes decades on end. One manager, one club.
Yet win percentages were more or the less same, back then, as they are today.
For example, if you look at a manager named Bob Masters, he was the gaffer at Nottingham Forest for 13 years. From 1912 to 1925. And his win percentage was 28%
But most of those managers listed above, all seventeen of them, had a win percentage the same or better than Bob Masters.
So why have they all been sacked?
Something is obviously rotten in football.
Fans, of course, like to blame the owners. And, at the end of the day, owners are the people who do the hiring and firing. And some of them can be very impatient.
But read any forum, for any club, and you will see very many fans clamouring for their current manager to be replaced.
Why? Why is it that fans today have so much less patience than fans of 100 years ago?
RE: Football managers - Duffers - 04-26-2021
I suppose the stakes are higher now for clubs and owners where getting promoted or avoiding relegation brings untold financial benefits. Championship clubs, especially the historically bigger ones, don’t want to or often can’t afford to, wait two/three years for a manager to build something. They need to get themselves up ASAP.
RE: Football managers - Borin' Baggie - 04-26-2021
(04-26-2021, 09:46 AM)Duffers Wrote: I suppose the stakes are higher now for clubs and owners where getting promoted or avoiding relegation brings untold financial benefits. Championship clubs, especially the historically bigger ones, don’t want to or often can’t afford to, wait two/three years for a manager to build something. They need to get themselves up ASAP.
Additionally, managers were a lot more generalised back then within the football clubs so getting rid of them meant they were more valuable to the clubs.
RE: Football managers - Logic1 - 04-26-2021
(04-26-2021, 09:42 AM)Baggy Bruin Wrote: Take one example. Nottingham Forest.
It is now April 2021.
How many managers have they had in the last 10 years?
1. Billy Davies was sacked in June 2011
2. Steve McLaren then had the job until October 2011
3. Steve Cotterill then had the job until July 2012
4. Sean O’Driscoll then had the job until December 2012
5. Alex McLeish then had the job until February 2013
6. Billy Davies returned and had the job until March 2014
7. Gary Brazil took over until May 2014
8. Stuart Pearce had the job until February 2015
9. Dougie Freedman had the job until March 2016
10. Paul Williams had the job until May 2016
11. Philip Montanier had the job until January 2017
12. Gary Brazil returned until March 2017
13. Mark Warburton had the job until December 2017
14. Aitor Karanka had the job until January 2019
15. Martin O’Neill had the job until June 2019
16. Sabri Lamouchi had the job until October 2020
and finally...
17. Chris Houghton is currently the manager of Nottingham Forest.
There is only one word to describe that, and it is SHAMBLES.
Back in the 1800s, through to the 1940s, football managers typically had their jobs for years, sometimes decades on end. One manager, one club.
Yet win percentages were more or the less same, back then, as they are today.
For example, if you look at a manager named Bob Masters, he was the gaffer at Nottingham Forest for 13 years. From 1912 to 1925. And his win percentage was 28%
But most of those managers listed above, all seventeen of them, had a win percentage the same or better than Bob Masters.
So why have they all been sacked?
Something is obviously rotten in football.
Fans, of course, like to blame the owners. And, at the end of the day, owners are the people who do the hiring and firing. And some of them can be very impatient.
But read any forum, for any club, and you will see very many fans clamouring for their current manager to be replaced.
Why? Why is it that fans today have so much less patience than fans of 100 years ago?

Also, back in the day - the team was often picked by a committee.
RE: Football managers - Shabby Russian - 04-26-2021
I am always a bit sceptical about the influence of managers and coaches.
A lot of the time it is about the club the players and how they gel with the manager, which seems to have more to do with luck than judgement.
The number of managers who get success with a club but can't replicate it elsewhere suggests that might be the case.
RE: Football managers - Fulham Fallout - 04-26-2021
(04-26-2021, 09:42 AM)Baggy Bruin Wrote: Take one example. Nottingham Forest.
It is now April 2021.
How many managers have they had in the last 10 years?
1. Billy Davies was sacked in June 2011
2. Steve McLaren then had the job until October 2011
3. Steve Cotterill then had the job until July 2012
4. Sean O’Driscoll then had the job until December 2012
5. Alex McLeish then had the job until February 2013
6. Billy Davies returned and had the job until March 2014
7. Gary Brazil took over until May 2014
8. Stuart Pearce had the job until February 2015
9. Dougie Freedman had the job until March 2016
10. Paul Williams had the job until May 2016
11. Philip Montanier had the job until January 2017
12. Gary Brazil returned until March 2017
13. Mark Warburton had the job until December 2017
14. Aitor Karanka had the job until January 2019
15. Martin O’Neill had the job until June 2019
16. Sabri Lamouchi had the job until October 2020
and finally...
17. Chris Houghton is currently the manager of Nottingham Forest.
There is only one word to describe that, and it is SHAMBLES.
Back in the 1800s, through to the 1940s, football managers typically had their jobs for years, sometimes decades on end. One manager, one club.
Yet win percentages were more or the less same, back then, as they are today.
For example, if you look at a manager named Bob Masters, he was the gaffer at Nottingham Forest for 13 years. From 1912 to 1925. And his win percentage was 28%
But most of those managers listed above, all seventeen of them, had a win percentage the same or better than Bob Masters.
So why have they all been sacked?
Something is obviously rotten in football.
Fans, of course, like to blame the owners. And, at the end of the day, owners are the people who do the hiring and firing. And some of them can be very impatient.
But read any forum, for any club, and you will see very many fans clamouring for their current manager to be replaced.
Why? Why is it that fans today have so much less patience than fans of 100 years ago?

Because it cost a lot less to attend games back then
No MOTD for pundits to slag us off
No internet and so couldn’t stream games back then
No social media to slag the team / players off on.
Maybeez
RE: Football managers - Bob Fossil - 04-26-2021
Chelsea have had 10 managers in the same period and won 8 major trophies, though.
Whether a team is good or bad comes down to one thing and that is money. We are rubbish this year but, with flexdown contracts, saleable assets and parachute payments we will be in the pound seats next.
Teams like Forest are where they are because they missed the boat when the odds were in their favour, i.e. when they first got relegated.
All this does is stress the importance of getting back up before these advantages run out, which we have, so far, managed to do every time, regardless of managerial turnaround.
RE: Football managers - Squid - 04-26-2021
(04-26-2021, 09:42 AM)Baggy Bruin Wrote: Take one example. Nottingham Forest.
It is now April 2021.
How many managers have they had in the last 10 years?
1. Billy Davies was sacked in June 2011
2. Steve McLaren then had the job until October 2011
3. Steve Cotterill then had the job until July 2012
4. Sean O’Driscoll then had the job until December 2012
5. Alex McLeish then had the job until February 2013
6. Billy Davies returned and had the job until March 2014
7. Gary Brazil took over until May 2014
8. Stuart Pearce had the job until February 2015
9. Dougie Freedman had the job until March 2016
10. Paul Williams had the job until May 2016
11. Philip Montanier had the job until January 2017
12. Gary Brazil returned until March 2017
13. Mark Warburton had the job until December 2017
14. Aitor Karanka had the job until January 2019
15. Martin O’Neill had the job until June 2019
16. Sabri Lamouchi had the job until October 2020
and finally...
17. Chris Houghton is currently the manager of Nottingham Forest.
There is only one word to describe that, and it is SHAMBLES.
Back in the 1800s, through to the 1940s, football managers typically had their jobs for years, sometimes decades on end. One manager, one club.
Yet win percentages were more or the less same, back then, as they are today.
For example, if you look at a manager named Bob Masters, he was the gaffer at Nottingham Forest for 13 years. From 1912 to 1925. And his win percentage was 28%
But most of those managers listed above, all seventeen of them, had a win percentage the same or better than Bob Masters.
So why have they all been sacked?
Something is obviously rotten in football.
Fans, of course, like to blame the owners. And, at the end of the day, owners are the people who do the hiring and firing. And some of them can be very impatient.
But read any forum, for any club, and you will see very many fans clamouring for their current manager to be replaced.
Why? Why is it that fans today have so much less patience than fans of 100 years ago?

That's not just about the fans, though? There's some truly appalling decision-making there by the boards of the time. You could probably do a similar list for Blues - Are they are a particularly difficult bunch of fans? No, they are just run by morons. Watford are notorious for chopping and changing, but they've got it right more often than not.
The average tenure of a manager is around 18 months. Bad managers get sacked and good managers get poached. As a side note, I see that for all people were doubting Darren Moore's ability as a manager, Doncaster have tumbled down the table without him.
RE: Football managers - coxy134 - 04-26-2021
Clubs being run as a profit making business with very short turn around/money back with a desire to play in premier league. That's why managers get turned around quick.
Gone are the days when we just want to watch a football game.
RE: Football managers - Derek Hardballs - 04-26-2021
(04-26-2021, 10:09 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Chelsea have had 10 managers in the same period and won 8 major trophies, though.
Whether a team is good or bad comes down to one thing and that is money. We are rubbish this year but, with flexdown contracts, saleable assets and parachute payments we will be in the pound seats next.
Teams like Forest are where they are because they missed the boat when the odds were in their favour, i.e. when they first got relegated.
All this does is stress the importance of getting back up before these advantages run out, which we have, so far, managed to do every time, regardless of managerial turnaround.
Exactly
|