WBAUnofficial
Our ageing squad - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Our ageing squad (/showthread.php?tid=14833)

Pages: 1 2


Our ageing squad - Gzbaggy - 01-07-2021

Ages of the following on 1.8.2012 for the start of the Championship!


Button 32

Peltier 34
Ivanovic 37
Bartley 30
Gibbs 31

Phillips 30
Livermore 31
Snodgrass 33
Grosicki 33

HRK 32
Austin 32

I know some of those will have gone but when people talk about selling players it is no wonder we perform poorly (compare us with Leicester and Southampton) when we insist on signing players with little re-sale value. Both of those trade far better on the transfer market than we do and I am sure it is not unrelated that is why we are   fighting relegation and they are not!

Why on earth we are signing Snodgrass on an 18 month contract is beyond me, perhaps we can give Edwards and Tulloch away

But is he?

His wages for 18 months will be well above the minimum wage!


RE: Our ageing squad - Baggie_Nick - 01-07-2021

(01-07-2021, 12:04 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Ages of the following on 1.8.2012 for the start of the Championship!


Button 32

Peltier 34
Ivanovic 37
Bartley 30
Gibbs 31

Phillips 30
Livermore 31
Snodgrass 33
Grosicki 33

HRK 32
Austin 32

I know some of those will have gone but when people talk about selling players it is no wonder we perform poorly (compare us with Leicester and Southampton) when we insist on signing players with little re-sale value. Both of those trade far better on the transfer market than we do and I am sure it is not unrelated that is why we are   fighting relegation and they are not!

Why on earth we are signing Snodgrass on an 18 month contract is beyond me, perhaps we can give Edwards and Tulloch away

He's cheap and no one else wants him.

Ask me another...


RE: Our ageing squad - Duffers - 01-07-2021

Or we could be playing Griffiths, O’Shea, Furlong, Field, Harper, Diangana, Pereira, Edwards, Grant, Robinson all of whom are 25 or younger...


RE: Our ageing squad - Dumbo - 01-07-2021

(01-07-2021, 12:09 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote:
(01-07-2021, 12:04 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Ages of the following on 1.8.2012 for the start of the Championship!


Button 32

Peltier 34
Ivanovic 37
Bartley 30
Gibbs 31

Phillips 30
Livermore 31
Snodgrass 33
Grosicki 33

HRK 32
Austin 32

I know some of those will have gone but when people talk about selling players it is no wonder we perform poorly (compare us with Leicester and Southampton) when we insist on signing players with little re-sale value. Both of those trade far better on the transfer market than we do and I am sure it is not unrelated that is why we are   fighting relegation and they are not!

Why on earth we are signing Snodgrass on an 18 month contract is beyond me, perhaps we can give Edwards and Tulloch away

He's cheap and no one else wants him.

Ask me another...

That’s no true.

West Ham fans want him to stay and there was interest from numerous Premier League clubs.


RE: Our ageing squad - CA Baggie - 01-07-2021

(01-07-2021, 12:04 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Ages of the following on 1.8.2012 for the start of the Championship!


Button 32

Peltier 34
Ivanovic 37
Bartley 30
Gibbs 31

Phillips 30
Livermore 31
Snodgrass 33
Grosicki 33

HRK 32
Austin 32

I know some of those will have gone but when people talk about selling players it is no wonder we perform poorly (compare us with Leicester and Southampton) when we insist on signing players with little re-sale value. Both of those trade far better on the transfer market than we do and I am sure it is not unrelated that is why we are   fighting relegation and they are not!

Why on earth we are signing Snodgrass on an 18 month contract is beyond me, perhaps we can give Edwards and Tulloch away

Or

Sam Johnstone 28

Fulong 25
Ajayi 27
O'Shea 22
Townsend 28

Kyle Edwards 23
Sam Field 23
Pereira 25
Diangana 23

Grant 23
Robinson 26

Suudenly we're a team that lacks experience and needs an old head.


RE: Our ageing squad - Duffers - 01-07-2021

We have a lot of young players who may or may not be ready for the PL, and a few players whose best PL days are behind.

We have very few who are actually in their prime right now. Ajayi maybe, and probably Johnstone - although even he is relatively young by keeper standards.


RE: Our ageing squad - Sliced - 01-07-2021

It's completely idealistic to think that having young players alone would be enough. We actually do have a young starting 11. The vast majority of the players you've listed a) won't be here and b) don't get in the first team anyway


RE: Our ageing squad - CA Baggie - 01-07-2021

(01-07-2021, 12:20 PM)Duffers Wrote: We have a lot of young players who may or may not be ready for the PL, and a few players whose best PL days are behind.

We have very few who are actually in their prime right now. Ajayi maybe, and probably Johnstone - although even he is relatively young by keeper standards.

In their prime costs money.

We did have several 10 years ago, but rarely did we actually buy players in their prime, many grew with us (Mozza, Brunt, Mulumbu, Jones).  If we did they'd often be gambles from abroad that probably wouldn't get through Brexit rules now!

(01-07-2021, 12:32 PM)Sliced Wrote: It's completely idealistic to think that having young players alone would be enough. We actually do have a young starting 11. The vast majority of the players you've listed a) won't be here and b) don't get in the first team anyway

It's not a team I'd pick I was just countering the OP that had all 30+players and bemoaning the age of the squad, when many of those won't be here for next season's championship either.


RE: Our ageing squad - Sliced - 01-07-2021

(01-07-2021, 12:34 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(01-07-2021, 12:20 PM)Duffers Wrote: We have a lot of young players who may or may not be ready for the PL, and a few players whose best PL days are behind.

We have very few who are actually in their prime right now. Ajayi maybe, and probably Johnstone - although even he is relatively young by keeper standards.

In their prime costs money.

We did have several 10 years ago, but rarely did we actually buy players in their prime, many grew with us (Mozza, Brunt, Mulumbu, Jones).  If we did they'd often be gambles from abroad that probably wouldn't get through Brexit rules now!

(01-07-2021, 12:32 PM)Sliced Wrote: It's completely idealistic to think that having young players alone would be enough. We actually do have a young starting 11. The vast majority of the players you've listed a) won't be here and b) don't get in the first team anyway

It's not a team I'd pick I was just countering the OP that had all 30+players and bemoaning the age of the squad, when many of those won't be here for next season's championship either.

I agree with you, I was responding to the OP also. Sorry, I realise now that wasn't clear at all


RE: Our ageing squad - Lurker#3 - 01-07-2021

The club have done a fine job in the last 2 years building a younger core. Is that core good enough for the Prem? No.

Would we have been good enough if we would have had a 'normal' non covid budget, say another 20/30 million to make 2 or 3 other key signings? Maybe not, but we would have been a hell of a lot closer.

The reality is we were both fortunate and unfortunate to go up this year. Fortunate in terms of us being able to get players like Robinson, Pereira, Diangana, Grant etc on perms who will be decent squad players for years to come. But unlucky that the global financial situation without us having a sugar daddy owner, has limited if not completely removed any hope of us competing properly.

We will go down. Big Sam will be gone. We will have a much changed squad next year with more 20/23 year old being signed, and we are likely to absolutely piss the league again.

Sit back, relax, strap in and enjoy the soap opera that football has now become.