WBAUnofficial
Athletic article on Bilic... - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Athletic article on Bilic... (/showthread.php?tid=13550)

Pages: 1 2


Athletic article on Bilic... - SW4Baggie - 11-03-2020

Excellent article posted today for those that subscribe.

Summary is that Bilic is managing with one hand behind his back, probably got us promoted a year too soon and it left us with too much to do. Dowling has gone well to squeeze the budget as he has done but maybe prioritising signing everyone from last year when it was still a very inexperienced Champ side was a mistake.

Whilst Bilic is understandably talking a lot of criticism at the moment, Lai and Ken’s silence is only mounting frustrations as fans project their anger towards the regime to the only face that’s publicly available in Slav.


RE: Athletic article on Bilic... - Big Daddy Cool - 11-03-2020

I found it a bit one sided as it seems to ignore our poor form in 2020


RE: Athletic article on Bilic... - Crossbar11 - 11-03-2020

Talk to us about 7 wins in 29 games , poor form since xmas.
Expect better from Madely


RE: Athletic article on Bilic... - HLS - 11-03-2020

I agree that he's got a tough job which is why I'm happy to give him the benefit of the doubt. However, I'm not sure I buy this 2 year plan story. Our best players were on loan with the exception of Pereira confirmed to stay and even if we had sold him for a profit, we'd be down on parachute payments, the loan players would have left and Livermore, Austin, HRK, Phillips and Gibbs would all be a year older. We'd have had to find a few more gems akin to Ajayi and the other loans and other effective champ players like Furlong and Sawyers (I add those two with much hesitation) to even meet the same standard in a more competitive championship than that first year.

If we go down with the whimper that's currently being served up, at least it might be the case nobody wants any of our most effective championship players, Diangana, Pereira, Robinson, Grant so we'll have a better platform to build off.

Either way, I just don't see how we could have gone up too early. Absolute nonsense in my opinion.


RE: Athletic article on Bilic... - TartanRug - 11-03-2020

(11-03-2020, 03:23 PM)Crossbar11 Wrote: Talk to us about 7 wins in 29 games , poor form since xmas.
Expect better from Madely

True but we overachieved IMO in the first half of last season, yes we were amongst the promotion favourites but the Summer before we had to replace the 'old guard' likes of Brunt, Morrison etc and freshen the whole squad up, a big task to get the new lot to play together so well up until the new year.


RE: Athletic article on Bilic... - SW4Baggie - 11-03-2020

(11-03-2020, 03:26 PM)HLS Wrote: I agree that he's got a tough job which is why I'm happy to give him the benefit of the doubt. However, I'm not sure I buy this 2 year plan story. Our best players were on loan with the exception of Pereira confirmed to stay and even if we had sold him for a profit, we'd be down on parachute payments, the loan players would have left and Livermore, Austin, HRK, Phillips and Gibbs would all be a year older. We'd have had to find a few more gems akin to Ajayi and the other loans and other effective champ players like Furlong and Sawyers (I add those two with much hesitation) to even meet the same standard in a more competitive championship than that first year.

If we go down with the whimper that's currently being served up, at least it might be the case nobody wants any of our most effective championship players, Diangana, Pereira, Robinson, Grant so we'll have a better platform to build off.

Either way, I just don't see how we could have gone up too early. Absolute nonsense in my opinion.

I think it’s more probably that we expected it would take 2 years to cycle the ageing squad following the playoff defeat and fashion a side capable of pushing for promotion using some canny recruitment and our youth - that was very much part of Dowling’s early comms.

What happened was that Bilic lured some quality loan players which got us up when the original plan was probably a slower, more long term rebuild. As the article says, we got promoted with a team of loans and no real striker... and if we roll back a year, most of us expected mid table to top 6 at best!


RE: Athletic article on Bilic... - baggiebloke - 11-03-2020

It's just as well we went up as financially it would have been fucking grim in the Covid years.


RE: Athletic article on Bilic... - Squid - 11-03-2020

A bit too much hinting. Why have Slav and Dowling fallen out? Hegazi, transfers, or something else?


RE: Athletic article on Bilic... - Super_Slav - 11-03-2020

(11-03-2020, 03:52 PM)Squid Wrote: A bit too much hinting. Why have Slav and Dowling fallen out? Hegazi, transfers, or something else?

They haven’t fallen out. I actually think they probably get on well. Bilić annoyance more with ownership IMO.


RE: Athletic article on Bilic... - Supamart - 11-03-2020

(11-03-2020, 03:45 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: It's just as well we went up as financially it would have been fucking grim in the Covid years.

Exactly