WBAUnofficial
Ratings and Onions... - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Ratings and Onions... (/showthread.php?tid=12709)

Pages: 1 2 3


Ratings and Onions... - Cuzer - 09-19-2020

Look, we had a two year plan to get up, we did it in one, we’re still weaker currently than the side that limped over the line against QPR, we know a few of them at least aren’t good enough at this level but are getting a chance
Throw in we’ve played two sides who are both likely top 5-8 and for 45 minutes today I thought we looked very good and for 55 minutes last week we held our own, try and take the positives

We need a striker, maybe two, a midfield worker and I’d wager another full back if Slav gets his way

SJ 6 Some good stops, little blame with the goals really, glued to his line as always and poor communication when defenders clearing the ball when he should be bellowing orders at the top of his voice, can’t see that ever changing

Furlong 3 Very poor today for me, was more guilty than anybody of being found out at set pieces and his shocking touch cost us for the first goal, one to forget

Gibbs 2 Playing great before the stupid red card, much further forward than last week and Rodriguez had barely had a touch before the goal, should know better and cost us

O Shea 4 some good, some bad, Slav likes him and learning the ropes but needs to learn quick, can’t fault effort or endeavor

Bartley 4 As above effort there but unlike O Shea doesn’t have age on his side, just not good enough at this level and never will be

Semi 5 Looks the best of the bunch but will be disappointed by his powder puff defending for their second. part of a defence that defend set pieces like a kids team, must improve

Sawyers 5 Better today, worked harder,still sloppy at times but an improvement on last week

Livermore 7 Tireless effort all game for me, never going to be the best on the ball but makes up for that with workrate and desire. So unlucky when hit the post 2-0 then who knows?

Grady 8* Constant threat when we got the ball to him in the right areas, great goal and looks more than capable at this level as we all know

Pereira 8 Great free kick and clever assist for Gradys goal, again as we know get him on the ball inntne final third and we have a chance

Robinson 7 Worked hard and led the line well for me, tireless running but at times clever movement to go with it, couple of final decisions he got wrong but showed promise I thought

Subs

Edwards 5 Little chance to get at them but tidy enough in possession

Phillips 5 Really could do with moving him on, if he’s a better option than the Pole god help us

Field 6 Good effort and work rate got some important interceptions in

Cuzer


RE: Ratings and Onions... - Sliced - 09-19-2020

Very good post


RE: Ratings and Onions... - Birdman1811 - 09-19-2020

Agree with all that Cuzer.


RE: Ratings and Onions... - Psalm23 - 09-19-2020

Amongst all the bollocks & negativity on here, at last a bit of fucking sense.


RE: Ratings and Onions... - igorbalis - 09-19-2020

Livermore 7? your having a laugh right?

The team played well today until a ridiculous VAR decision and a cheating fuckin colombian decides to get Gibbs sent off.

We more than matched Everton until then - even when we pulled it back to 2-2 I fancied us to get something from the game, but fuck me defensive shambles for their third and that just killed it for us.

Chelski next - bring it on.


RE: Ratings and Onions... - oldun - 09-19-2020

(09-19-2020, 05:06 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Look, we had a two year plan to get up, we did it in one, we’re still weaker currently than the side that limped over the line against QPR, we know a few of them at least aren’t good enough at this level but are getting a chance
Throw in we’ve played two sides who are both likely top 5-8 and for 45 minutes today I thought we looked very good and for 55 minutes last week we held our own, try and take the positives

We need a striker, maybe two, a midfield worker and I’d wager another full back if Slav gets his way

SJ 6 Some good stops, little blame with the goals really, glued to his line as always and poor communication when defenders clearing the ball when he should be bellowing orders at the top of his voice, can’t see that ever changing

Furlong 3 Very poor today for me, was more guilty than anybody of being found out at set pieces and his shocking touch cost us for the first goal, one to forget

Gibbs 2 Playing great before the stupid red card, much further forward than last week and Rodriguez had barely had a touch before the goal, should know better and cost us

O Shea 4 some good, some bad, Slav likes him and learning the ropes but needs to learn quick, can’t fault effort or endeavor

Bartley 4 As above effort there but unlike O Shea doesn’t have age on his side, just not good enough at this level and never will be

Semi 5 Looks the best of the bunch but will be disappointed by his powder puff defending for their second. part of a defence that defend set pieces like a kids team, must improve

Sawyers 5 Better today, worked harder,still sloppy at times but an improvement on last week

Livermore 7 Tireless effort all game for me, never going to be the best on the ball but makes up for that with workrate and desire. So unlucky when hit the post 2-0 then who knows?

Grady 8* Constant threat when we got the ball to him in the right areas, great goal and looks more than capable at this level as we all know

Pereira 8 Great free kick and clever assist for Gradys goal, again as we know get him on the ball inntne final third and we have a chance

Robinson 7 Worked hard and led the line well for me, tireless running but at times clever movement to go with it, couple of final decisions he got wrong but showed promise I thought

Subs

Edwards 5 Little chance to get at them but tidy enough in possession

Phillips 5 Really could do with moving him on, if he’s a better option than the Pole god help us

Field 6 Good effort and work rate got some important interceptions in

Cuzer



RE: Ratings and Onions... - Kit Kat Chunky - 09-19-2020

a realistic assessment, Cuzer, especially with the players that we need to have a fighting chance.


RE: Ratings and Onions... - AnelkasBeard - 09-19-2020

Agree with all that Cuzer, it's especially hard to judge the second half given the situation.

I kept thinking about that chance Robinson had where he tried to square it to Grady instead of having a pop. I really think he could've beaten Pickford there, and at 3-3, maybe we find some mental fortitude, and keep going.

One positive to take is how good Diangana and Pereira have looked. Get them an actual striker (Robinson has played well, but he isn't an out and out striker) to play off, and I think our attack and counterattack will be excellent.

Let's just hope Slav can sort the defence...


RE: Ratings and Onions... - oldun - 09-19-2020

(09-19-2020, 05:06 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Look, we had a two year plan to get up, we did it in one, we’re still weaker currently than the side that limped over the line against QPR, we know a few of them at least aren’t good enough at this level but are getting a chance
Throw in we’ve played two sides who are both likely top 5-8 and for 45 minutes today I thought we looked very good and for 55 minutes last week we held our own, try and take the positives

We need a striker, maybe two, a midfield worker and I’d wager another full back if Slav gets his way

SJ 6 Some good stops, little blame with the goals really, glued to his line as always and poor communication when defenders clearing the ball when he should be bellowing orders at the top of his voice, can’t see that ever changing

Furlong 3 Very poor today for me, was more guilty than anybody of being found out at set pieces and his shocking touch cost us for the first goal, one to forget

Gibbs 2 Playing great before the stupid red card, much further forward than last week and Rodriguez had barely had a touch before the goal, should know better and cost us

O Shea 4 some good, some bad, Slav likes him and learning the ropes but needs to learn quick, can’t fault effort or endeavor

Bartley 4 As above effort there but unlike O Shea doesn’t have age on his side, just not good enough at this level and never will be

Semi 5 Looks the best of the bunch but will be disappointed by his powder puff defending for their second. part of a defence that defend set pieces like a kids team, must improve

Sawyers 5 Better today, worked harder,still sloppy at times but an improvement on last week

Livermore 7 Tireless effort all game for me, never going to be the best on the ball but makes up for that with workrate and desire. So unlucky when hit the post 2-0 then who knows?

Grady 8* Constant threat when we got the ball to him in the right areas, great goal and looks more than capable at this level as we all know

Pereira 8 Great free kick and clever assist for Gradys goal, again as we know get him on the ball inntne final third and we have a chance

Robinson 7 Worked hard and led the line well for me, tireless running but at times clever movement to go with it, couple of final decisions he got wrong but showed promise I thought

Subs

Edwards 5 Little chance to get at them but tidy enough in possession

Phillips 5 Really could do with moving him on, if he’s a better option than the Pole god help us

Field 6 Good effort and work rate got some important interceptions in

Cuzer

Not sure how the gk can be glued to his line as usual, but take no blame for 6 yard box goals?


RE: Ratings and Onions... - MancBaggie - 09-19-2020

(09-19-2020, 05:12 PM)Sliced Wrote: Very good post

+1. Good summary Cuz